Zandstra E H, Stubenitsky K, De Graaf C, Mela D J
Division of Human Nutrition and Epidemiology, Wageningen University, P.O. Box 8129, 6700 EV Wageningen, The Netherlands.
Physiol Behav. 2002;75(1-2):83-90. doi: 10.1016/s0031-9384(01)00647-3.
The present study examined the effects of repeated midmorning consumption of novel-flavoured low- and high-energy yoghurt drinks on subsequent energy intake at lunch in 69 adults under actual use conditions. Subjects consumed 200 ml of low- and high-energy yoghurt drinks (67 and 273 kcal/200 ml, respectively), with 20 exposures to each drink on alternate days. Analyses focused on the development of compensation for the differences in energy content of the beverages, due to learned satiety. Results revealed incomplete energy compensation for the beverages, both at first exposure and also after 20 exposures. Relative to the no-yoghurt condition, energy intake compensation (+/-S.E.M.) averaged 39+/-36% for the low-energy yoghurt and 17+/-9% for the high-energy version, with no evidence of any change in compensation with repeated exposures. When the flavours of the yoghurt drinks were covertly switched after 20 exposures, subjects increased their energy intake after the high-energy yoghurt drink containing the flavour that was previously coupled with the low-energy yoghurt drink. Vice versa, however, when subjects switched to the low-energy yoghurt drink containing the high-energy flavour, subjects ignored the flavour cue and ate the same lunch size regardless of the energy in the yoghurt drink. We conclude that adults do not readily acquire accurate conditioned adjustments for the energy content in food after repeated experience with the food in free-living natural-eating conditions.
本研究在实际使用条件下,对69名成年人上午多次食用新型口味的低能量和高能量酸奶饮料后午餐时的后续能量摄入影响进行了考察。受试者分别饮用200毫升低能量和高能量酸奶饮料(分别为67千卡/200毫升和273千卡/200毫升),每隔一天每种饮料饮用20次。分析重点在于因习得饱腹感而对饮料能量含量差异进行补偿的发展情况。结果显示,无论是首次饮用还是饮用20次后,对饮料的能量补偿都不完整。与不喝酸奶的情况相比,低能量酸奶的能量摄入补偿(±标准误)平均为39±36%,高能量酸奶为17±9%,且没有证据表明重复饮用后补偿有任何变化。在饮用20次后将酸奶饮料的口味暗中切换时,饮用过之前与低能量酸奶饮料搭配过口味的高能量酸奶饮料后,受试者增加了能量摄入。然而,反之,当受试者换成含有高能量口味的低能量酸奶饮料时,受试者忽略了口味提示,无论酸奶饮料中的能量如何,午餐食量相同。我们得出结论,在自由生活的自然饮食条件下,成年人在多次接触食物后,不会轻易对食物中的能量含量进行准确的条件性调整。