Schneider B, Wendler J, Seidner W
Klinische Abteilung für Phoniatrie-Logopädie, Universitäts-Hals-Nasen-Ohren-Klinik, Allgemeines Krankenhaus der Stadt Wien, Osterreich.
Folia Phoniatr Logop. 2002 Jan-Feb;54(1):44-54. doi: 10.1159/000048595.
Functional dysphonias are disorders of the voice characterized by sound and efficiency disturbances of the voice without any organic changes of structures being detectable. At present, functional dysphonias are generally subclassified into hyper- and hypofunctional dysphonias in clinical practice.
The study was designed for a critical evaluation of the relevance of stroboscopy to the diagnostics and classification of functional dysphonias.
45 patients were examined (27 hyperfunctional, 15 hypofunctional and 3 mixed type) using videostroboscopy. Several stroboscopic parameters were taken into consideration. Three geometrical and three time-dependent parameters were first analyzed in a uni- and multidimensional way, then cluster analyses were performed.
We could not confirm the clinical subdivision into hyper- and hypofunctional dysphonias as based on anamnestic data, perceptual evaluation of voice sound, voice profile measurements and videostroboscopy. Quantitative measurements of selected parameters did not correlate with qualitative subjective stroboscopic assessment. In addition to this, it was not possible to identify separate clusters of stroboscopic findings.
The results do not deny the clinical relevance of stroboscopy to the diagnostics of functional dysphonias as a very useful tool to exclude organic lesions. However, a reliable subclassification into different types of functional dysphonias was not possible.
功能性发声障碍是一种嗓音疾病,其特征为嗓音存在音质和发声效率方面的障碍,而未检测到任何结构上的器质性改变。目前,在临床实践中,功能性发声障碍通常被分为功能亢进性和功能减退性发声障碍。
本研究旨在对频闪喉镜检查在功能性发声障碍的诊断和分类中的相关性进行批判性评估。
对45例患者(27例功能亢进性、15例功能减退性和3例混合型)进行了视频频闪喉镜检查。考虑了几个频闪喉镜参数。首先对三个几何参数和三个时间相关参数进行了单维和多维分析,然后进行了聚类分析。
我们无法根据既往病史数据、嗓音的感知评估、嗓音剖面图测量以及视频频闪喉镜检查结果,证实临床将功能性发声障碍分为功能亢进性和功能减退性发声障碍的分类方法。所选参数的定量测量结果与定性主观频闪喉镜评估结果不相关。除此之外,无法识别频闪喉镜检查结果的不同聚类。
这些结果并不否认频闪喉镜检查在功能性发声障碍诊断中的临床相关性,它是排除器质性病变的一种非常有用的工具。然而,无法可靠地将功能性发声障碍分为不同类型。