Becker Howard C, Veatch Lynn M
Medical Research, Department of Veterans Affairs, The Charleston Alcohol Research Center, 67 President Street, Charleston, SC 29425, USA.
Alcohol Clin Exp Res. 2002 Mar;26(3):371-80.
Although many alcohol-dependent patients present with a history of prior detoxifications, the efficacy and safety of pharmacotherapy in the context of multiple ethanol withdrawal experiences have not been extensively studied. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the ability of lorazepam treatment for multiple withdrawals to prevent or blunt the development/expression of sensitized central nervous system hyperexcitability during a subsequent untreated withdrawal episode. A mouse model of withdrawal sensitization involving repeated ethanol withdrawals was used.
Adult male C3H/He mice were exposed to different patterns of chronic ethanol vapor in inhalation chambers. One group received four cycles of 16 hr of ethanol exposure separated by 8-hr withdrawal periods, another group was tested after a single 16-hr exposure period, and a final group served as ethanol-naïve controls. These groups were further divided into lorazepam dosage (0.25-1.0 mg/kg) conditions. Lorazepam was administered 1 hr into each of the first three withdrawal cycles (or equivalent times); no drug injections were given during the final (fourth) withdrawal cycle. The ability of lorazepam treatment to alter development and expression of sensitized handling-induced convulsions (HIC), as well as changes in pentylenetetrazol seizure threshold dosage during an untreated withdrawal episode, was examined. Separate animals were used to assess the effects of lorazepam treatment on blood ethanol clearance and plasma levels of the benzodiazepine during the test withdrawal cycle.
Lorazepam dose-dependently reduced HIC activity during successive withdrawal cycles, and this resulted in attenuated expression of the sensitized HIC response during the acute phase of a subsequent untreated withdrawal episode. However, HIC activity was exacerbated at later time points during this final test withdrawal in mice that had received lorazepam treatment for earlier withdrawals. A similar pattern of results was obtained for changes in pentylenetetrazol seizure threshold dosage. These results do not seem to be due to pharmacokinetic factors, because peak blood ethanol levels, rate of ethanol elimination, and plasma levels of lorazepam did not significantly differ among groups during the final test withdrawal cycle.
Blocking central nervous system hyperexcitability during repeated ethanol withdrawals with lorazepam effectively blunts the development and expression of sensitized seizure activity during the acute phase of a subsequent unmedicated withdrawal episode. At later time points, withdrawal-related seizure activity was exacerbated, and this is possibly reflective of an interaction between protracted ethanol withdrawal and withdrawal from the benzodiazepine. The clinical implications of these findings suggest that repeated use of benzodiazepines for treatment of multiple ethanol withdrawals may have some initial beneficial effects, but such treatment may also place patients at increased risk of seizures at later time points.
尽管许多酒精依赖患者有过先前戒酒的经历,但在多次乙醇戒断的情况下药物治疗的疗效和安全性尚未得到广泛研究。本研究的目的是评估劳拉西泮治疗多次戒断的能力,以预防或减轻在随后未经治疗的戒断发作期间致敏的中枢神经系统过度兴奋的发展/表现。使用了涉及重复乙醇戒断的戒断致敏小鼠模型。
成年雄性C3H/He小鼠在吸入室中暴露于不同模式的慢性乙醇蒸气。一组接受四个周期的16小时乙醇暴露,中间间隔8小时的戒断期,另一组在单次16小时暴露期后进行测试,最后一组作为未接触过乙醇的对照。这些组进一步分为劳拉西泮剂量(0.25 - 1.0毫克/千克)条件。在最初三个戒断周期的每个周期开始1小时(或等效时间)给予劳拉西泮;在最后(第四个)戒断周期不进行药物注射。研究了劳拉西泮治疗改变致敏的处理诱导惊厥(HIC)的发展和表现的能力,以及在未经治疗的戒断发作期间戊四氮惊厥阈值剂量的变化。使用单独的动物评估劳拉西泮治疗对测试戒断周期期间血液乙醇清除率和苯二氮䓬血浆水平的影响。
劳拉西泮在连续的戒断周期中剂量依赖性地降低了HIC活性,这导致在随后未经治疗的戒断发作急性期致敏的HIC反应的表达减弱。然而,在接受过劳拉西泮治疗早期戒断的小鼠的最后一次测试戒断后期时间点,HIC活性加剧。对于戊四氮惊厥阈值剂量的变化也获得了类似的结果模式。这些结果似乎不是由于药代动力学因素,因为在最后测试戒断周期期间,各组之间的血液乙醇峰值水平、乙醇消除率和劳拉西泮血浆水平没有显著差异。
在重复乙醇戒断期间用劳拉西泮阻断中枢神经系统过度兴奋有效地减轻了在随后未用药的戒断发作急性期致敏的癫痫活动的发展和表现。在后期时间点,与戒断相关的癫痫活动加剧,这可能反映了长期乙醇戒断与苯二氮䓬戒断之间的相互作用。这些发现的临床意义表明,重复使用苯二氮䓬治疗多次乙醇戒断可能有一些初始有益效果,但这种治疗也可能使患者在后期时间点癫痫发作风险增加。