Furukawa Toshiharu, Kitajima Masaki
Department of Surgery, School of Medicine, Keio University, Tokyo, Japan.
Nihon Geka Gakkai Zasshi. 2002 Mar;103(3):309-13.
The principle of medical safety management is to build a safe medical system that is equipped to prevent patient injuries due to medical errors occurring in it and not to attribute them only to individual responsibility. Methodologically, this means identifying and reducing the potential risk of medical errors by systematic reporting and tracking of errors and near misses. According to some major clinical studies on medical malpractice in the USA, the incidence of medical accidents is reported to be 3-5%, 30% of which were due to negligence, and 7-14% resulted in patients' deaths. It is also reported that 66% of the medical accidents occurred in surgical specialties and 45% were related to surgeries, which were shown to have the highest risk of medical accidents. On the other hand, according to a nationwide survey on reported errors and near misses in Japan, 50% were related to drugs, especially injections. Other major causes reported in the study were manipulation and management of medical instruments, downfalls of patients, and aspiration. These safety problems listed above were shown to compose 95% of all of medical errors and near misses. To establish a rational safety management system, it is necessary to develop research methods appropriate for the study of medical errors, which facilitate clinical research, and can be expected to yield sufficient scientific data. A generalized guideline for voluntary reporting of patients' deaths and injuries due to medical errors, in relation to Article 21 of the Doctors' Law should be established. However, for essential improvement of transparency and accountability in medicine, it is necessary to set up a new specialized institute to accept reports on medical errors, give hospitals advice for a safer medical system, and disclose information on medical errors. Moreover, such an institute should continue to study medical safety by analyzing nationwide reports of medical errors and near misses. For the latter purpose, legal protection of the disclosure of information must be assured.
医疗安全管理的原则是建立一个安全的医疗系统,该系统应具备预防因其中发生的医疗差错而导致患者受伤的能力,而不是仅仅将其归咎于个人责任。从方法上讲,这意味着通过系统地报告和追踪差错及险些发生的差错来识别并降低医疗差错的潜在风险。根据美国一些关于医疗事故的主要临床研究,据报道医疗事故的发生率为3%至5%,其中30%是由于疏忽,7%至14%导致患者死亡。另据报道,66%的医疗事故发生在外科专业,45%与手术有关,手术显示出医疗事故风险最高。另一方面,根据日本一项关于报告的差错及险些发生的差错的全国性调查,50%与药物有关,尤其是注射用药。该研究报告的其他主要原因包括医疗器械的操作与管理、患者跌倒和误吸。上述这些安全问题构成了所有医疗差错及险些发生的差错的95%。为建立合理的安全管理系统,有必要开发适合医疗差错研究的研究方法,这些方法有助于临床研究,并有望产生足够的科学数据。应制定与《医师法》第21条相关的关于自愿报告因医疗差错导致患者死亡和受伤情况的通用指南。然而,为从根本上提高医疗领域的透明度和问责制,有必要设立一个新的专门机构,以接收关于医疗差错的报告,为医院提供建立更安全医疗系统的建议,并披露医疗差错信息。此外,这样一个机构应通过分析全国范围内关于医疗差错及险些发生的差错的报告,持续开展医疗安全研究。为实现后一目标,必须确保信息披露的法律保护。