Joseph E D
Psychoanal Q. 1975;44(4):526-33.
The Ego and the Id has served as an organizing model which has advanced psychoanalysis as a science and as a therapy. The paradigm offered by the structural formulations provided a framework for many developmental and clinical studies as well as an approach to a general psychology of human behavior. Therapeutic advances have been made, but the art of therapy has not kept pace with the scientific advances. Dissatisfaction with psychoanalysis and psychoanalytic theory is discussed. Theories have become too far removed from their clinical base; a changing sociologic climate that has reduced the impact of the rational attitude offered by psychoanalysis and the failure of psychoanalytic therapy to cure all ills have contributed to the dissatisfaction.
《自我与本我》作为一种组织模型,推动了精神分析成为一门科学和一种治疗方法。结构公式所提供的范式为许多发展性和临床研究提供了框架,也为人类行为的一般心理学提供了一种方法。治疗方面取得了进展,但治疗艺术并未跟上科学进展。文中讨论了对精神分析和精神分析理论的不满。理论已与临床基础脱节太远;社会环境的变化削弱了精神分析所提供的理性态度的影响,以及精神分析疗法未能治愈所有疾病,这些都导致了不满。