Christiaens Thierry C M, Digranes Asbjørn, Baerheim Anders
Department of General Practice and Primary Health Care, The University of Ghent, Belgium.
Scand J Prim Health Care. 2002 Mar;20(1):45-9. doi: 10.1080/028134302317282743.
Overuse of antimicrobial drugs has resulted in an alarming increase in bacterial resistance in most countries. The relevance for general practice is unknown.
To evaluate the impact of the sale of antimicrobial drugs on bacterial resistance as found in uropathogens from general practice.
General practice in Belgium and Norway.
Observational study.
The sale of antimicrobial drugs indicated for use in the treatment of urinary tract infection was four times higher in Belgium than in Norway (18.5 vs 4.4 DDD/1000 inhabitants/day). The antibiotic resistance reported by microbiological laboratories as valid for general practice was significant higher in Belgium than in Norway (ampicillins (44% vs 27%), co-trimoxazole (28% vs 17%), fluoroquinolones (12% vs 2%) and nitrofurantoin (16% vs 11%, p < 0.0001 for all). However, the antibiotic resistance found in urine samples from dysuric women in general practice was similar (trimethoprim 14% vs 12%, co-trimoxazole 14% vs 11%, nitrofurantoin 7% vs 3%), except in the case of ampicillins (30% vs 19%, p < 0.05).
The impact of the antimicrobial sale on resistance in uropathogens seems less than expected at the general practice level, even though local microbiological reports mention fairly high antibiotic resistance data. Adapted methods for following-up bacterial resistance evolution in general practice are needed.
在大多数国家,抗菌药物的过度使用已导致细菌耐药性惊人地增加。其对全科医疗的影响尚不清楚。
评估抗菌药物销售对全科医疗中尿路病原体细菌耐药性的影响。
比利时和挪威的全科医疗。
观察性研究。
比利时用于治疗尿路感染的抗菌药物销售量比挪威高四倍(18.5对4.4限定日剂量/1000居民/天)。微生物实验室报告的对全科医疗有效的抗生素耐药性在比利时显著高于挪威(氨苄西林(44%对27%)、复方新诺明(28%对17%)、氟喹诺酮类(12%对2%)和呋喃妥因(16%对11%,所有p<0.0001)。然而,全科医疗中排尿困难女性尿液样本中的抗生素耐药性相似(甲氧苄啶14%对12%、复方新诺明14%对11%、呋喃妥因7%对3%),氨苄西林除外(30%对19%,p<0.05)。
尽管当地微生物学报告提及相当高的抗生素耐药性数据,但在全科医疗层面,抗菌药物销售对尿路病原体耐药性的影响似乎小于预期。需要采用适合的方法来跟踪全科医疗中细菌耐药性的演变。