O'Halloran Maria, Carr Alan, O'Reilly Gary, Sheerin Declan, Cherry Joan, Turner Rhonda, Beckett Richard, Brown Sarah
Department of Psychology, Mid Western Health Board, Limerick, Ireland.
Child Abuse Negl. 2002 Apr;26(4):349-70. doi: 10.1016/s0145-2134(02)00313-7.
This study aimed to profile the psychological and psychosocial characteristics of a group of Irish adolescents who had sexually abused other youngsters.
Levels of behavior problems, personal adjustment, anger management, and psychosocial adjustment were compared in 27 Irish adolescents with a history of sexually abusing another youngster (SA group), 20 clinical controls who had significant behavioral problems but no history of sexual offending (CC group), and 29 normal controls who were without significant psychological problems (NC group). Measures used included the Child Behavior Checklist (CBCL), the Youth Self-Report Form (YSR), selected scales from Beckett (1997) Adolescent Sex Offender Assessment Pack (ASOAP), and the Family Environment Scale (FES).
Compared with the CC group, the SA group displayed fewer problems overall on the CBCL and the YSR. The SA group showed problems with self-esteem, emotional loneliness, and perspective-taking similar to those of the CC group, but their impulsivity scores were similar to those of the NC group. The locus of control scores of the SA group fell between those of the CC and NC groups. The SA group showed an anger management profile that fell at an intermediate position between those of the NC and CC groups. The SA group showed problematic family functioning in the areas of expressiveness, behavior control, and social support, similar to those of the CC group. Their difficulties with family cohesion were less severe than those of the CC group but worse than those of the NC group.
Overall, the psychological adjustment of adolescents with a history of sexually abusing others was more problematic than that of normal controls but less problematic than that of youngsters who had significant behavioral problems but no history of sexual offending.
本研究旨在剖析一群对其他青少年实施过性虐待的爱尔兰青少年的心理和社会心理特征。
比较了27名有性虐待其他青少年史的爱尔兰青少年(性虐待组)、20名有严重行为问题但无性犯罪史的临床对照组(临床对照组)和29名无明显心理问题的正常对照组(正常对照组)的行为问题水平、个人调适、愤怒管理和社会心理调适情况。所使用的测量工具包括儿童行为清单(CBCL)、青少年自我报告表(YSR)、从贝克特(1997年)青少年性犯罪者评估包(ASOAP)中选取的量表以及家庭环境量表(FES)。
与临床对照组相比,性虐待组在CBCL和YSR上总体显示出较少的问题。性虐待组在自尊、情感孤独和换位思考方面存在与临床对照组类似的问题,但其冲动性得分与正常对照组相似。性虐待组的控制点得分介于临床对照组和正常对照组之间。性虐待组的愤怒管理情况处于正常对照组和临床对照组之间的中间位置。性虐待组在表达性、行为控制和社会支持等方面显示出有问题的家庭功能,与临床对照组类似。他们在家庭凝聚力方面的困难比临床对照组轻,但比正常对照组严重。
总体而言,有性虐待他人史的青少年的心理调适比正常对照组问题更多,但比有严重行为问题但无性犯罪史的青少年问题更少。