Udomratn Pichet, Srisurapanont Manit
Department of Psychiatry, Faculty of Medicine, Prince of Songkla University, Hat Yai, Songkhla, Thailand.
Neuropsychobiology. 2002;45(4):186-90. doi: 10.1159/000063669.
This study aimed to determine the impact of a particular clinical practice guideline (CPG) following its passive dissemination on Thai psychiatrists' prescribing attitudes towards treatment-resistant schizophrenia (TRS). Two surveys were conducted before and after the dissemination of the CPG. Ninety-four questionnaires from the first survey and 84 from the second were analysed. Over 70% of the respondents were male. The mean age and duration of practice were 42.3 and 15.3 years, respectively. The respondents' characteristics were not significantly different in sex, age, years of practice, specialty, or clinical setting. In the first survey, the first three favoured interventions for TRS were switching to risperidone alone, switching to another conventional antipsychotic (CA), and adding carbamazepine to the on-going CA. In the second round, the first three interventions were switching to risperidone alone, switching to another CA, and switching to clozapine alone. Although there was a trend in the direction suggested by the CPG, there was no significant difference between the two surveys. The interventions chosen as first, second-, and third-line treatments were also not significantly different. Of 80 respondents who expressed their opinions on the CPG, 55, 15, and 10 stated that they knew, did not know, and were uncertain about the availability of a guideline, respectively. Of 55 respondents who knew about the availability of the guideline, 40 had read it. The mean (SDs) of the guideline acceptance and the impact of the guideline on the practice obtained from those 40 respondents were 70.9 (13.7) and 58.9 (19.6), respectively.
本研究旨在确定一项特定临床实践指南(CPG)在被动传播后对泰国精神科医生针对难治性精神分裂症(TRS)的处方态度的影响。在CPG传播前后进行了两项调查。对第一次调查的94份问卷和第二次调查的84份问卷进行了分析。超过70%的受访者为男性。平均年龄和执业年限分别为42.3岁和15.3年。受访者在性别、年龄、执业年限、专业或临床环境方面的特征无显著差异。在第一次调查中,针对TRS最受青睐的前三项干预措施是单独换用利培酮、换用另一种传统抗精神病药物(CA)以及在正在使用的CA基础上加用卡马西平。在第二轮调查中,前三项干预措施是单独换用利培酮、换用另一种CA以及单独换用氯氮平。尽管存在CPG所建议方向的趋势,但两次调查之间无显著差异。被选为一线、二线和三线治疗的干预措施也无显著差异。在80名对CPG发表意见的受访者中,55人、15人以及10人分别表示他们知道、不知道以及不确定是否有该指南。在55名知道有该指南的受访者中,40人阅读过。从这40名受访者获得的指南接受度平均值(标准差)以及指南对实践的影响分别为70.9(13.7)和58.9(19.6)。