Olusina Adewunmi K, Ohaeri Jude U, Olatawura Michael O
Department of Psychiatry, College of Medicine, University of Ibadan, Nigeria.
Soc Psychiatry Psychiatr Epidemiol. 2002 Jun;37(6):283-8. doi: 10.1007/s00127-002-0548-5.
Patient satisfaction has been proposed as a simple measure of the quality of care. The present study aimed to assess how satisfied the patients and staff in an acute admission psychiatric unit were with experiences in the ward, including the physical environment, freedom, comfort, attitudes of staff towards patients, access to staff, and duration of hospitalization.
A descriptive study of all patients admitted for functional psychiatric disorders in a 5-month period was conducted. Patients and staff completed similar 16-item self-rated Likert-type questionnaires. Satisfaction was graded as follows: dissatisfaction < 50 % positive appreciation), bare satisfaction (50-65 %), moderate (66-74 %), and highest satisfaction (> or = 75 %).
The 118 patients were dissatisfied with items that indicated curtailment of their freedom, while the 35 staff were dissatisfied with the physical facilities for care. Highest satisfaction for patients and staff were for items on staff-patient relationship. Barely satisfactory items for patients included the time spent with doctors. Patients had a higher positive appraisal of the adequacy of physical facilities than staff, while staff had a more positive appraisal of their relationship with patients. There were no significant differences in satisfaction among diagnostic groups.
The logical and discriminating manner in which patients assessed satisfaction supports the impression that they can be relied upon to make objective appraisal of the process of care, and that patient satisfaction is a valid index of the quality of care.
患者满意度已被提议作为衡量医疗质量的一项简单指标。本研究旨在评估急性入院精神科病房的患者和工作人员对病房体验的满意程度,包括物理环境、自由度、舒适度、工作人员对患者的态度、与工作人员接触的机会以及住院时长。
对在5个月期间因功能性精神障碍入院的所有患者进行了一项描述性研究。患者和工作人员完成了类似的包含16个项目的自填式李克特量表问卷。满意度分级如下:不满意(<50%正面评价)、勉强满意(50 - 65%)、中等满意(66 - 74%)和高度满意(≥75%)。
118名患者对表明其自由受限的项目不满意,而35名工作人员对护理的物理设施不满意。患者和工作人员对医患关系项目的满意度最高。患者勉强满意的项目包括与医生相处的时间。患者对物理设施充足性的正面评价高于工作人员,而工作人员对其与患者关系的评价更为正面。各诊断组之间的满意度无显著差异。
患者评估满意度时合乎逻辑且具有区分性的方式支持了这样一种观点,即可以依靠他们对护理过程进行客观评价,并且患者满意度是护理质量的有效指标。