Remnik Yulia, Melamed Yuval, Swartz Marnina, Elizur Avner, Barak Yoram
Yehuda Abarbanel Mental Health Center, Bat-Yam, Israel.
Isr J Psychiatry Relat Sci. 2004;41(3):208-12.
Patient satisfaction with medical treatment is important, and although in mental health the literature on the topic is scant, awareness of the issue is rapidly growing.
Evaluation of patient satisfaction among hospitalized psychiatric patients.
100 consenting patients (47 men and 53 women) were surveyed and completed a questionnaire regarding satisfaction with psychiatric care.
Fifty-nine percent of the patients were in a new modern building, 41% were in an older hospital building; 21% were in a psycho-geriatric ward. The various settings allowed comparison across different environments.
Most participants expressed mild general satisfaction. The overall rating was 3.40 +/- 0.43 (range 1-5). The ratings were similar regarding the various components of treatment: satisfaction with the nursing staff, physical conditions on the ward and treatment per se. Positive correlation was found between satisfaction with nursing and overall ratings.
Inpatients were mildly satisfied with treatment. However, no correlation was found between satisfaction and either the type of case manager or the physical conditions in the ward. Further research is needed to characterize specific variables that may influence patient satisfaction with psychiatric care. In addition, the question of whether self-report evaluation questionnaires are appropriate for the inpatient psychiatric population should be addressed.
患者对医疗治疗的满意度很重要,尽管在心理健康领域关于该主题的文献较少,但对这一问题的认识正在迅速增长。
评估住院精神科患者的满意度。
对100名同意参与的患者(47名男性和53名女性)进行调查,并完成一份关于对精神科护理满意度的问卷。
59%的患者住在新建的现代化大楼里,41%住在旧的医院大楼里;21%住在老年精神科病房。这些不同的环境允许在不同环境之间进行比较。
大多数参与者表示总体满意度一般。总体评分是3.40±0.43(范围为1 - 5)。在治疗的各个方面评分相似:对护理人员的满意度、病房的物理条件和治疗本身。在对护理的满意度和总体评分之间发现了正相关。
住院患者对治疗的满意度一般。然而,在满意度与个案管理员类型或病房物理条件之间未发现相关性。需要进一步研究以确定可能影响患者对精神科护理满意度的具体变量。此外,应探讨自我报告评估问卷是否适用于住院精神科患者群体的问题。