Nour Sherif Gamal, Aschoff Andrik J, Mitchell Ian C S, Emancipator Steven N, Duerk Jeffrey L, Lewin Jonathan S
Dept of Radiology, Univ Hospitals of Cleveland/Case Western Reserve Univ School of Medicine, 11100 Euclid Ave, Cleveland, OH 44106-5056, USA.
Radiology. 2002 Aug;224(2):452-62. doi: 10.1148/radiol.2242011269.
To test the hypotheses that (a) magnetic resonance (MR) imaging-guided radio-frequency (RF) thermal ablation of the vertebrae is feasible in porcine models, (b) procedure safety depends on the location of ablation within the vertebra, and (c) MR imaging allows accurate monitoring of induced thermal lesion size and shape.
Ten percutaneous MR imaging-guided RF thermal ablations were randomized over various lumbar vertebral levels and locations in seven pigs. Animals were followed up for 2, 7, or 14 days before sacrifice. Thermal lesion size and shape as measured on MR images obtained immediately after ablation and at follow-up were compared with gross pathologic findings. Mean absolute differences between lesion diameters at pathologic examination and MR imaging were evaluated by using a paired t test, as were differences between lesion-to-vertebra contrast-to-noise ratios obtained for each sequence. Clinical and imaging data were correlated with histologic findings.
Successful RF electrode placement in the targeted part of the vertebra was achieved in all procedures. Ablations performed away from neural elements were safe to perform. Pedicular ablations resulted in radiculopathy, whereas ablations performed directly over the posterior cortex resulted in paraplegia. Lesion sizes measured on T2-weighted images were closest to those measured at gross pathologic examination (mean absolute difference, 0.72 mm +/- 0.83 [SD]), followed by those measured on contrast material-enhanced T1-weighted (1.27 mm +/- 0.83) and short inversion time inversion-recovery (STIR) (1.5 mm +/- 1.84) images. Size measurements obtained on T2-weighted images were significantly closer to gross pathologic measurements than were those obtained on contrast-enhanced T1-weighted images (P =.013) but were not different from those obtained on STIR (P =.27) images. The contrast-to-noise ratio was significantly higher for contrast-enhanced T1-weighted images than for T2-weighted (P <.001) or STIR (P <.001) images.
MR imaging-guided RF thermal ablation of the vertebrae is feasible in porcine models, but the safety of the procedure depends on the location of ablation within the vertebra. MR imaging allows accurate monitoring of thermal lesion size and shape.
验证以下假设:(a) 在猪模型中,磁共振(MR)成像引导下的射频(RF)椎体热消融是可行的;(b) 手术安全性取决于椎体消融的位置;(c) MR成像能够准确监测诱导热损伤的大小和形状。
对7头猪的不同腰椎水平和位置进行了10次经皮MR成像引导下的RF热消融,并随机分组。在处死动物前,对其进行2天、7天或14天的随访。将消融后立即获得的以及随访时的MR图像上测量的热损伤大小和形状与大体病理结果进行比较。采用配对t检验评估病理检查和MR成像时损伤直径的平均绝对差异,以及每个序列获得的损伤与椎体对比噪声比之间的差异。将临床和影像数据与组织学结果进行关联分析。
所有手术均成功将RF电极放置在椎体的目标部位。远离神经组织进行的消融操作是安全的。椎弓根消融导致神经根病,而直接在后皮质上方进行的消融导致截瘫。在T2加权图像上测量的损伤大小最接近大体病理检查时测量的大小(平均绝对差异为0.72 mm±0.83 [标准差]),其次是在对比剂增强T1加权(1.27 mm±0.83)和短反转时间反转恢复(STIR)(1.5 mm±1.84)图像上测量的大小。在T2加权图像上获得的大小测量值比在对比增强T1加权图像上获得的测量值显著更接近大体病理测量值(P = 0.013),但与在STIR(P = 0.27)图像上获得的测量值无差异。对比增强T1加权图像的对比噪声比显著高于T2加权(P < 0.001)或STIR(P < 0.001)图像。
在猪模型中,MR成像引导下的RF椎体热消融是可行的,但手术安全性取决于椎体消融的位置。MR成像能够准确监测热损伤的大小和形状。