Goldberg Jay R, Gilbert Jeremy L, Jacobs Joshua J, Bauer Thomas W, Paprosky Wayne, Leurgans Sue
Department of Biomedical Engineering, Marquette University and Biophysics Research Institute, Medical College of Wisconsin, Milwaukee, 53201-1881, USA.
Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2002 Aug(401):149-61. doi: 10.1097/00003086-200208000-00018.
A multicenter retrieval analysis of 231 modular hip implants was done to investigate the effects of material combination, metallurgic condition, flexural rigidity, head and neck moment arm, neck length, and implantation time on corrosion and fretting of modular taper surfaces. Scores for corrosion and fretting were assigned to medial, lateral, anterior, and posterior quadrants of the necks, and proximal and distal regions of the heads. Neck and head corrosion and fretting scores were found to be significantly higher for mixed alloy versus similar alloy couples. Moderate to severe corrosion was observed in 28% of the heads of similar alloy couples and 42% of the heads of mixed alloy couples. Differences in corrosion scores were observed between components made from the same base alloy, but of different metallurgic conditions. Corrosion and fretting scores tended to be higher for heads than necks. Implantation time and flexural rigidity of the neck were predictors of head and neck corrosion and head fretting. The results of this study suggest that in vivo corrosion of modular hip taper interfaces is attributable to a mechanically-assisted crevice corrosion process. Larger diameter necks will increase neck stiffness and may reduce fretting and subsequent corrosion of the taper interface regardless of the alloy used. Increasing neck diameter must be balanced, however, with the resulting loss of range of motion and joint stability.
对231个模块化髋关节植入物进行了多中心检索分析,以研究材料组合、冶金条件、抗弯刚度、头颈力臂、颈长和植入时间对模块化锥面腐蚀和微动磨损的影响。将腐蚀和微动磨损评分分配给颈部的内侧、外侧、前方和后方象限以及头部的近端和远端区域。发现混合合金配对相对于相似合金配对的颈部和头部腐蚀及微动磨损评分显著更高。在相似合金配对的头部中,28%观察到中度至重度腐蚀,在混合合金配对的头部中,42%观察到中度至重度腐蚀。由相同基础合金制成但冶金条件不同的部件之间观察到腐蚀评分存在差异。头部的腐蚀和微动磨损评分往往高于颈部。植入时间和颈部的抗弯刚度是头部和颈部腐蚀以及头部微动磨损的预测因素。本研究结果表明,模块化髋关节锥面的体内腐蚀归因于机械辅助缝隙腐蚀过程。无论使用何种合金,较大直径的颈部将增加颈部刚度,并可能减少锥面接口的微动磨损和随后的腐蚀。然而,增加颈部直径必须与由此导致的活动范围和关节稳定性的损失相平衡。