Gibanel R, Ribal M J, Filella X, Ballesta A M, Molina R, Alcaraz A, Alcover J B
Department of Urology and Renal Transplantation, Hospital Clinic, Barcelona, Spain.
Anticancer Res. 2002 Mar-Apr;22(2B):1157-60.
Among urinary tumor markers we studied the utility of the BTA TRAK assay to diagnose transitional cell carcinoma of the bladder in highly suspiscious patients, in comparison to urine cytology.
A preliminary study of 65 patients was made (21 transitional cell carcinoma (TCC), 36 without TCC and 8 excluded patients who received BCG therapy, endocavitary mytomicin or radiotherapy), using the BTA TRAK, cytology and cystoscopy.
12 out of the 21 selected patients were pTa (9 G1and 3 G2), 2 carcinoma in situ (CIS), 2pT1 (1 G2 and 1 G3) and 5 muscle invasive tumors (all of them G3). Setting our cut-off at 18 U/ml, a sensitivity of 52.3% and a specificity of 88.9% was reached. BTA TRAK detected 11 out of 21 of the tumors as well as urine cytology. However, BTA TRAK was more sensitive in the detection of low grade tumors (p<0.05). When considering both tests as complementary, a combined sensitivity of 80.9% and specificity of 88.5% were obtained.
BTA TRAK is a valid test for the diagnosis of TCC of the bladder, which is not superior to urine cytology but complementary. More extensive prospective studies are required to validate this application and others of the BTA TRAK assay used either alone or in combination with urinary cytology in the management of bladder cancerpatients.
在尿肿瘤标志物中,我们研究了BTA TRAK检测法在高度可疑患者中诊断膀胱移行细胞癌的效用,并与尿细胞学检查进行比较。
对65例患者进行了初步研究(21例移行细胞癌(TCC),36例无TCC,8例接受卡介苗治疗、腔内丝裂霉素或放疗的排除患者),采用BTA TRAK、细胞学检查和膀胱镜检查。
21例入选患者中,12例为pTa(9例G1和3例G2),2例原位癌(CIS),2例pT1(1例G2和1例G3),5例肌层浸润性肿瘤(均为G3)。将临界值设定为18 U/ml时,灵敏度为52.3%,特异性为88.9%。BTA TRAK检测出21例肿瘤中的11例,与尿细胞学检查结果相同。然而,BTA TRAK在检测低级别肿瘤方面更敏感(p<0.05)。当将两种检测方法视为互补时,联合灵敏度为80.9%,特异性为88.5%。
BTA TRAK是诊断膀胱TCC的有效检测方法,它并不优于尿细胞学检查,但具有互补性。需要更广泛的前瞻性研究来验证这种应用以及BTA TRAK检测法单独或与尿细胞学检查联合用于膀胱癌患者管理的其他应用。