Koski Anna, Ojanperä Ilkka, Vuori Erkki
Laboratory of Toxicology, Department of Forensic Medicine, University of Helsinki, Finland.
Alcohol Clin Exp Res. 2002 Jul;26(7):956-9. doi: 10.1097/01.ALC.0000021337.78063.67.
Postmortem forensic toxicology frequently finds alcohol both alone and in combination with drugs. Although benzodiazepines are generally considered safe, they are considered dangerous with alcohol.
A retrospective statistical analysis of alcohol and benzodiazepine concentrations in postmortem blood samples included 808 cases diagnosed as fatal alcohol or drug intoxication involving (1) ethanol alone; (2) ethanol with temazepam; or (3) ethanol with any combination of diazepam, chlordiazepoxide, and nordazepam.
The median concentration of ethanol was 3.3 per thousand in cases with ethanol alone and 3.5 per thousand when diazepam was present, but it was significantly lower, only 2.5 per thousand, when temazepam was present in the blood. Furthermore, the median concentration of ethanol was 2.2 per thousand in cases with high concentrations (>0.9 mg/liter) of temazepam and 2.7 per thousand in cases with therapeutic (< or =0.9 mg/liter) concentrations.
Diazepam and chlordiazepoxide pose a smaller risk of death by poisoning than does temazepam when given as a hypnotic to patients suffering from alcoholism.
法医学尸检毒理学经常发现单独存在的酒精以及与药物混合存在的酒精。尽管苯二氮䓬类药物通常被认为是安全的,但与酒精同时存在时则被视为危险药物。
对尸检血样中的酒精和苯二氮䓬类药物浓度进行回顾性统计分析,纳入了808例被诊断为致命酒精或药物中毒的病例,这些病例涉及:(1)仅乙醇;(2)乙醇与替马西泮;或(3)乙醇与地西泮、氯氮䓬和去甲西泮的任意组合。
仅乙醇中毒的病例中乙醇的中位浓度为千分之3.3,存在地西泮时为千分之3.5,但当血液中存在替马西泮时,乙醇浓度显著更低,仅为千分之2.5。此外,替马西泮浓度高(>0.9毫克/升)的病例中乙醇的中位浓度为千分之2.2,治疗浓度(≤0.9毫克/升)的病例中为千分之2.7。
对于酗酒患者,作为催眠药使用时,地西泮和氯氮䓬导致中毒死亡的风险比替马西泮小。