Kolb R, Priesching A, Czech W, Dahlberg B E, Kratochwil A
Wien Klin Wochenschr. 1975 Jul 18;87(14):455-9.
The relative diagnostic accuracy of clinical examination, mammography, thermography and ultrasound was investigated in a comparative study. Mammography proved to be the most accurate diagnostic method, followed by clinical examination, thermography and ultrasound. Whereas in cases of advanced cancer (T2 to T4 tumour diameter greater than 2 cm) the correct diagnosis was made most reliably by clinical examination, mammography was superior to all other procedures in T1 tumours and in impalpable tumours. In our opinion thermography and ultrasound should be excluded for routine use or as a screening test because of the high false negative results. It is, however, noteworthy, that small intraparenchymal cysts can be detected and localized by ultrasound in a very high percentage of cases.
在一项对比研究中,对临床检查、乳房X线摄影、热成像和超声检查的相对诊断准确性进行了调查。结果表明,乳房X线摄影是最准确的诊断方法,其次是临床检查、热成像和超声检查。在晚期癌症病例(肿瘤直径大于2 cm的T2至T4期)中,临床检查最可靠地做出了正确诊断,而在T1期肿瘤和不可触及的肿瘤中,乳房X线摄影优于所有其他检查方法。我们认为,由于假阴性结果较高,热成像和超声检查不应作为常规使用或筛查测试。然而,值得注意的是,超声检查在很高比例的病例中能够检测到并定位小的实质内囊肿。