Stannard James P, Wilson Timothy C, Sheils Todd M, McGwin Gerald, Volgas David A, Alonso Jorge E
Department of Surgery, Division of Orthopaedic Surgery, The University of Alabama at Birmingham, Birmingham, Alabama 35294-3295, USA.
Arthroscopy. 2002 Oct;18(8):835-9. doi: 10.1053/jars.2002.32842.
The purpose of this study was to determine the prevalence of heterotopic ossification following knee dislocation.
Prospective clinical evaluation and a retrospective chart review.
This study evaluated 57 knees in 55 patients who sustained high-energy blunt trauma with resultant knee dislocations. Radiographs were reviewed by 2 of the authors (J.P.S., T.C.W.), and the incidence of heterotopic ossification (HO) was documented. Additionally, patients were classified regarding the degree of HO on a scale from 0 to 4. One is punctate calcification, 2 is HO involving less than 50% of the joint space; 3 is HO involving more than 50%; and 4 is ankylosis of the joint.
Thirteen patients with 15 knee dislocations developed HO. The incidence of HO was 26%. Seven knees demonstrated severe HO (grade 3 or 4) which represented an incidence of 12% of all knee dislocations. Injury severity score for both groups was 18, documenting that the patients in this study represent multiple trauma patients. There was no significant difference in the incidence of HO based on mechanism of injury with the current number enrolled in the study. However, 60% (3 of 5) of patients involved in a motor vehicle versus pedestrian accident developed HO. There was a significant increase in the incidence of arthrofibrosis in patients with severe HO (P <.05). Patients with significant HO had a mean flexion of 97 degrees, compared with flexion of 117 degrees in patients with no or mild HO. This difference was borderline significant (P =.058). There was no difference between the groups in mean extension. There was a significant increase in knee HO in patients with HO at another anatomic site (P =.01).
HO is a common problem following knee dislocation. Of the 7 knees with severe HO, 5 developed HO medially, 4 developed HO posteriorly, 3 developed HO laterally, and only 1 had involvement anteriorly. A similar distribution was present in the patients with mild HO, with posterior and medial ossification being the most common. Five of the 7 severe HO cases involved at least 3 of the 4 sides (anterior, posterior, medial, or lateral) of the knee. Patients were evaluated for the presence of head injury and any relationship to the development of HO around the knee. There was no increased incidence of HO around the knee in our 10 patients with severe head injuries when compared with those with no head injury. There was also no increased incidence of HO in knee dislocations associated with periarticular fractures.
本研究旨在确定膝关节脱位后异位骨化的发生率。
前瞻性临床评估和回顾性病历审查。
本研究评估了55例因高能钝性创伤导致膝关节脱位的患者的57个膝关节。两位作者(J.P.S.,T.C.W.)对X线片进行了审查,并记录了异位骨化(HO)的发生率。此外,根据HO的程度将患者分为0至4级。1级为点状钙化,2级为HO累及关节间隙小于50%;3级为HO累及超过50%;4级为关节强直。
13例患者的15个膝关节脱位后发生了HO。HO的发生率为26%。7个膝关节表现为严重HO(3级或4级),占所有膝关节脱位的12%。两组的损伤严重程度评分均为18,表明本研究中的患者为多发伤患者。根据损伤机制,本研究目前纳入的患者中HO的发生率没有显著差异。然而,在机动车与行人事故中的患者有60%(5例中的3例)发生了HO。严重HO患者的关节纤维性变发生率显著增加(P<.05)。严重HO患者的平均屈曲度为97度,而无HO或轻度HO患者的屈曲度为117度。这种差异接近显著(P =.058)。两组的平均伸展度没有差异。在另一个解剖部位有HO的患者中,膝关节HO的发生率显著增加(P =.01)。
HO是膝关节脱位后的常见问题。在7个严重HO的膝关节中,5个在内侧发生HO,4个在后方发生HO,3个在外侧发生HO,只有1个在前侧发生HO。轻度HO患者也有类似的分布,以后方和内侧骨化最为常见。7例严重HO病例中有5例累及膝关节的4个面(前、后、内或外)中的至少3个面。对患者进行了头部损伤的评估以及其与膝关节周围HO发生的任何关系。与无头部损伤的患者相比,我们10例严重头部损伤患者膝关节周围HO的发生率没有增加。与关节周围骨折相关的膝关节脱位中HO的发生率也没有增加。