Feldman Heidi M, MacWhinney Brian, Sacco Kelley
Children's Hospital of Pittsburgh, University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine, 3705 Fifth Avenue, Pittsburgh, PA 15212, USA.
Brain Lang. 2002 Nov;83(2):335-52. doi: 10.1016/s0093-934x(02)00037-8.
This study examined how children use word order and animacy cues to determine the agent of the action in an on-line sentence-comprehension task. The subject group included 15 children, 5-12 years old, with brain injury incurred prior to the age of 2 months; 12 had left hemisphere (LH) damage and 3 had right hemisphere (RH) damage. The comparison group included 141 children, 5-10 years old, who were at the appropriate grade for age. The task required children to listen to sentences composed of two noun phrases (N) that varied in terms of animacy and a verb phrase (V) and then to indicate the agent of the action. Three word orders were presented: NVN, VNN, and NNV. Measures included the proportion of trials in which the first noun was selected (choice) and reaction time. Word order and animacy significantly influenced choice. The effect of subject group approached significance for choice. Word order and age influenced reaction time. The children with LH injury and two children with RH injury showed a developmental delay in choosing the appropriate N as agent; one child with RH injury had mature responses. The overlapping performance of children with LH and RH injury suggests that delays in the development of sentence comprehension strategies are more likely related to reliance on a smaller than usual neural network rather than to congenital specialization of the LH.
本研究考察了儿童在一项在线句子理解任务中如何利用词序和生命性线索来确定动作的施事者。实验组包括15名年龄在5至12岁之间、在2个月大之前就遭受脑损伤的儿童;其中12名儿童左半球(LH)受损,3名儿童右半球(RH)受损。对照组包括141名年龄在5至10岁之间、处于相应年龄年级的儿童。该任务要求儿童听由两个在生命性方面不同的名词短语(N)和一个动词短语(V)组成的句子,然后指出动作的施事者。呈现了三种词序:NVN、VNN和NNV。测量指标包括选择第一个名词的试验比例(选择)和反应时间。词序和生命性对选择有显著影响。实验组对选择的影响接近显著水平。词序和年龄影响反应时间。左半球受损的儿童以及两名右半球受损的儿童在选择合适的名词作为施事者时表现出发育延迟;一名右半球受损的儿童反应成熟。左半球和右半球受损儿童的表现重叠表明,句子理解策略发展的延迟更可能与依赖比正常情况更小的神经网络有关,而不是与左半球的先天性特化有关。