Laohaprasitiporn Duangmanee, Nana Apichart, Soongswang Jarupim, Durongpisitkul Kritvikrom, Kangkagate Charuwan, Rochanasiri Wandee, Pooranawattanakul Sukanya
Department of Pediatrics, Faculty of Medicine Siriraj Hospital, Mahidol University, Bangkok, Thailand.
J Med Assoc Thai. 2002 Aug;85 Suppl 2:S630-9.
Transcatheter coil occlusion of small-to-moderate-size patent ductus arteriosus (PDA, < 3.5 mm) is well established as a procedure of first choice in many institutions. Its much lower cost compared with surgical ligation or other devices makes it an attractive option, especially in Thailand.
Between September 1995 and June 2000, all patients diagnosed with PDA with audible murmur and echo-Doppler confirmation of diameter less than 3.5 mm were scheduled for transcatheter coil occlusion at the Department of Pediatrics, Faculty of Medicine Siriraj Hospital. The hemodynamic studies were obtained both pre and post occlusion. The immediate and late outcome, including complication were assessed.
A total of 77 cases, 78 procedures of transcatheter PDA coil occlusion were performed. Seventy cases (90.9%), comprised of 19 males (27.1%) and 51 females (72.9%) were successfully deployed with coils. The remainder were unsuccessfully deployed and later referred to surgery. The median age of the successful group was 6 years and 6 months and median weight was 16.5 kg. Twenty cases (28.6%) had other associated intra and extracardiac anomalies. All patients were asymptomatic, except one case having bronchopulmonary dysplasia (BPD) from prolonged ventilation. Single-coil occlusions were performed in 74.3 per cent and double-coil occlusions in 25.7 per cent. Conventional 0.038-inch Gianturco coils were deployed in 86.5 per cent. The mean procedure time was 78.1 +/- 35.1 minutes. The mean fluoroscopic time was 20.2 +/- 15.6 minutes. The total complete occlusion rate was 87.7 per cent. Tiny residual flow of PDA was demonstrated by follow-up echocardiogram in 12.3 per cent. Seven per cent of the patients were lost to follow-up. There was no significant difference in PDA size and hemodynamics between the groups of patients with complete occlusion and having residual shunt. Minor complications occurred in 12.9 per cent, including mild left pulmonary artery stenosis (10%), coil embolization to distal pulmonary artery (8.6%), slippage of catheter with coil (2.9%) and decreased dorsalis pedis pulse (1.4%). One late death was found in a BPD patient from pneumonia 2 months after the procedure.
Transcatheter coil occlusion of PDA is as effective, feasible, safe and less costly than surgical ligation. With improvement in technique and device selection and appropriate case selection, there should be an increase rate of complete occlusion and a decrease in complications.
经导管弹簧圈封堵小至中等大小的动脉导管未闭(PDA,<3.5mm)在许多机构已被确立为首选治疗方法。与手术结扎或其他装置相比,其成本低得多,这使其成为一个有吸引力的选择,尤其是在泰国。
1995年9月至2000年6月期间,所有经听诊有杂音且经超声心动图 - 多普勒证实直径小于3.5mm的动脉导管未闭患者,均在诗里拉吉医院医学院儿科学系安排进行经导管弹簧圈封堵术。封堵前后均进行了血流动力学研究。评估了即刻和远期结果,包括并发症。
共进行了77例患者的78次经导管动脉导管未闭弹簧圈封堵术。70例(90.9%)成功植入弹簧圈,其中男性19例(27.1%),女性51例(72.9%)。其余患者植入失败,随后转诊进行手术。成功组的中位年龄为6岁6个月,中位体重为16.5kg。20例(28.6%)有其他心脏内和心脏外相关异常。除1例因长时间通气患有支气管肺发育不良(BPD)外,所有患者均无症状。74.3%的患者采用单弹簧圈封堵,25.7%的患者采用双弹簧圈封堵。86.5%的患者使用传统的0.03英寸吉安特科弹簧圈。平均手术时间为78.1±35.1分钟。平均透视时间为20.2±15.6分钟。总完全封堵率为87.7%。随访超声心动图显示12.3%的患者动脉导管未闭有微小残余分流。7%的患者失访。完全封堵组和有残余分流组患者的动脉导管未闭大小和血流动力学无显著差异。12.9%的患者出现轻微并发症,包括轻度左肺动脉狭窄(10%)、弹簧圈栓塞至远端肺动脉(8.6%)、导管带弹簧圈滑脱(2.9%)和足背动脉搏动减弱(1.4%)。1例BPD患者在术后2个月因肺炎死亡。
经导管弹簧圈封堵动脉导管未闭与手术结扎一样有效、可行、安全且成本更低。随着技术和装置选择的改进以及病例选择的恰当,完全封堵率应会提高,并发症会减少。