Constable Peter D, Morin Dawn E
Department of Veterinary Clinical Medicine, College of Veterinary Medicine, University of Illinois, Urbana 61802, USA.
J Am Vet Med Assoc. 2002 Jul 1;221(1):103-8. doi: 10.2460/javma.2002.221.103.
To determine whether results of antimicrobial susceptibility testing of bacterial pathogens isolated from the milk of dairy cows with clinical mastitis were associated with duration of clinical signs or bacteriologic cure rate following treatment with cephapirin and oxytetracycline.
Observational study on a convenience sample.
58 dairy cows with 121 episodes of clinical mastitis.
Cows that only had abnormal glandular secretions were treated with cephapirin alone. Cows with an inflamed gland and abnormal glandular secretions were treated with oxytetracycline and cephapirin. Cows with systemic signs of illness, an inflamed gland, and abnormal glandular secretions were treated with oxytetracycline and flunixin meglumine and frequent stripping of the affected glands. The Kirby-Bauer method was used for antimicrobial susceptibility testing, and current guidelines were used to categorize causative bacteria as susceptible or resistant to the treatment regimen.
Median durations of episodes of clinical mastitis caused by susceptible (n = 97) and resistant (24) bacteria were not significantly different. Bacteriologic cure rates at 14 and 28 days were similar for episodes caused by susceptible and resistant bacteria; however, for 56 episodes of clinical mastitis caused by gram-positive bacteria and treated with cephapirin alone, bacteriologic cure rate at 28 days was significantly higher for susceptible than for resistant bacteria.
Results suggest that antimicrobial susceptibility testing was of no value in predicting duration of clinical signs or bacteriologic cure rate in dairy cows with mastitis, except for episodes caused by gram-positive organisms treated with intramammary administration of cephapirin alone.
确定从患有临床型乳腺炎的奶牛乳汁中分离出的细菌病原体的药敏试验结果是否与临床症状持续时间或头孢匹林和土霉素治疗后的细菌学治愈率相关。
对便利样本进行观察性研究。
58头奶牛,发生121次临床型乳腺炎。
仅出现异常腺体分泌物的奶牛单独使用头孢匹林治疗。腺体发炎且有异常腺体分泌物的奶牛使用土霉素和头孢匹林治疗。出现全身疾病体征、腺体发炎且有异常腺体分泌物的奶牛使用土霉素和氟尼辛葡甲胺治疗,并对患侧腺体频繁挤奶。采用 Kirby-Bauer 方法进行药敏试验,并按照现行指南将致病细菌分类为对治疗方案敏感或耐药。
由敏感菌(n = 97)和耐药菌(24)引起的临床型乳腺炎发作的中位持续时间无显著差异。敏感菌和耐药菌引起的发作在14天和28天的细菌学治愈率相似;然而,对于56次由革兰氏阳性菌引起且仅用头孢匹林治疗的临床型乳腺炎发作,28天时敏感菌的细菌学治愈率显著高于耐药菌。
结果表明,药敏试验在预测乳腺炎奶牛的临床症状持续时间或细菌学治愈率方面无价值,除了由革兰氏阳性菌引起且仅通过乳房内注射头孢匹林治疗的发作。