Stolper C F, Rutten A L B, Lugten R F G, Barthels R J W M
Commissie Methode en Validering VHAN (Dutch Association of Homeopathic Physicians), Heerde, Netherlands.
Homeopathy. 2002 Oct;91(4):230-8. doi: 10.1054/homp.2002.0054.
A committee of the Dutch Association of Homeopathic Physicians is trying to validate materia medica by evaluating successful cases. These cases are presented and assessed by a group of experienced homeopathic physicians to provide indications about the prevalence of symptoms related to particular homeopathic medicines. The next logical question is whether epidemiological techniques can be applied to them. We have some ideas concerning the information these data can provide, based on epidemiological theory and limited experimental data. Theoretical investigation suggests that the epidemiological concept of likelihood ratio is well adapted to homeopathy. Researching and applying likelihood ratio will lead to more accurate materia medica and repertory. These considerations already indicate some shortcomings in the representation of rare remedies and the use of grading in the current repertories.
荷兰顺势疗法医师协会的一个委员会正在试图通过评估成功案例来验证药物学。这些案例由一组经验丰富的顺势疗法医师进行展示和评估,以提供与特定顺势疗法药物相关症状的患病率指标。接下来合乎逻辑的问题是,流行病学技术是否可以应用于这些案例。基于流行病学理论和有限的实验数据,我们对这些数据所能提供的信息有一些想法。理论研究表明,似然比的流行病学概念非常适合顺势疗法。研究和应用似然比将带来更准确的药物学和药典。这些考虑已经表明了当前药典中稀有药物的呈现方式和分级使用方面的一些缺陷。