Vögeli Thomas A, Burchardt Martin, Fornara Paolo, Rassweiler Jens, Sulser Tullio
Department of Urology, University of Düsseldorf, Moorenstrasse 5, Düsseldorf 40225, Germany.
Eur Urol. 2002 Nov;42(5):441-6. doi: 10.1016/s0302-2838(02)00399-8.
A survey was performed to assess the current practice patterns in laparoscopy among urologists in Germany and Switzerland.
Using the database directory of the German and Swiss Urological Association urological departments were identified. A detailed questionnaire was designed and sent by postal service. Responding questionnaires were analyzed.
The overall response rate was 64%. Fifty-four percent of respondents in Germany and 33% in Switzerland already perform laparoscopy; another 50% and 56% are planning to introduce laparoscopy. Thirty-six percent think that laparoscopy is economical and 77% await shortening of hospital stay. Major concerns are: Economical aspects, lengthy learning curve, investment, and lack of scientific data. The number of laparoscopic procedures during 12 months was registered for 19 indications. More than 40 procedures for one indication are performed by only 6% of the departments.
The survey reveals an increasing number of departments performing laparoscopy and broad acceptance of the technology but combined with some major concerns. Currently only a minority of the departments perform more than 40 procedures for one indication suggesting that at present laparoscopy is mainly a center-based technology.
开展一项调查以评估德国和瑞士泌尿外科医生当前的腹腔镜手术实践模式。
利用德国和瑞士泌尿外科学会的数据库目录确定泌尿外科科室。设计了一份详细问卷并通过邮政服务发送。对回复的问卷进行分析。
总体回复率为64%。德国54%的受访者和瑞士33%的受访者已经开展腹腔镜手术;另外,德国50%和瑞士56%的受访者计划引入腹腔镜手术。36%的人认为腹腔镜手术经济实惠,77%的人期待缩短住院时间。主要担忧包括:经济方面、学习曲线长、投资以及缺乏科学数据。记录了19种适应证在12个月内的腹腔镜手术数量。仅6%的科室针对一种适应证进行了超过40例手术。
该调查显示开展腹腔镜手术的科室数量在增加,且该技术得到广泛认可,但也存在一些主要担忧。目前只有少数科室针对一种适应证进行超过40例手术,这表明目前腹腔镜手术主要是一种以中心为基础的技术。