Priebe Stefan, Dielentheis Thomas F
Unit for Social and Community Psychiatry, Barts and the London School of Medicine, Queen Mary, University of London, UK.
Psychiatr Prax. 2002 Nov;29(8):420-3. doi: 10.1055/s-2002-35511.
Investigations of treatment costs are of increasing importance in community mental health care. Yet, they are often difficult and expensive to conduct. This study explores whether and, if so, to what extent direct treatment costs as paid by insurance companies and social welfare in the German health care system can be estimated through a simple Institutionalisation-Index.
Based on the literature and clinical judgment, a simple Institutionalisation-Index was formed reflecting the degree of institutional protection in supported housing, long-term day care, partial hospitalisation and full hospitalisation programmes. As part of a comprehensive evaluation of a model institution for community mental health care in Berlin, actually paid treatment costs and Institutionalisation-Index (II) were identified for 1194 patients over a total period of 23 years and compared with each other.
The Pearson correlation coefficient between II and paid costs was 0.97 (p < 0,001). In calculations for subgroups and different periods of time, II and costs were almost identical, too.
The Institutionalisation-Index provides a sufficiently precise estimate of direct costs as paid by insurance companies and social welfare for different forms of care in community based institutions and hospitals. The II can be adjusted to incorporate further forms of community based care. In systems with similar funding arrangements, the simple method to establish a Institutionalisation-Index should facilitate cost analyses in community mental health care.
在社区精神卫生保健中,治疗成本的调查愈发重要。然而,此类调查往往难度大且成本高。本研究探讨能否通过一个简单的机构化指数来估算德国医疗保健系统中保险公司和社会福利所支付的直接治疗成本,若能,则估算到何种程度。
基于文献和临床判断,形成了一个简单的机构化指数,以反映在支持性住房、长期日间护理、部分住院和全面住院项目中的机构保护程度。作为对柏林一个社区精神卫生保健示范机构综合评估的一部分,确定了23年期间1194名患者的实际治疗成本和机构化指数(II),并进行相互比较。
II与支付成本之间的皮尔逊相关系数为0.97(p < 0.001)。在亚组和不同时间段的计算中,II与成本也几乎相同。
机构化指数能够对保险公司和社会福利为社区机构和医院中不同形式护理所支付的直接成本进行足够精确的估算。II可进行调整以纳入更多形式的社区护理。在具有类似资金安排的系统中,建立机构化指数的简单方法应有助于社区精神卫生保健中的成本分析。