Siewerdsen J H, Cunningham I A, Jaffray D A
Department of Radiation Oncology, William Beaumont Hospital, Royal Oak, Michigan 48073, USA.
Med Phys. 2002 Nov;29(11):2655-71. doi: 10.1118/1.1513158.
A methodological framework for experimental analysis of the noise-power spectrum (NPS) of multidimensional images is presented that employs well-known properties of the n-dimensional (nD) Fourier transform. The approach is generalized to n dimensions, reducing to familiar cases for n = 1 (e.g., time series) and n = 2 (e.g., projection radiography) and demonstrated experimentally for two cases in which n = 3 (viz., using an active matrix flat-panel imager for x-ray fluoroscopy and cone-beam CT to form three-dimensional (3D) images in spatiotemporal and volumetric domains, respectively). The relationship between fully nD NPS analysis and various techniques for analyzing a "central slice" of the NPS is formulated in a manner that is directly applicable to measured nD data, highlights the effects of correlation, and renders issues of NPS normalization transparent. The spatiotemporal NPS of fluoroscopic images is analyzed under varying conditions of temporal correlation (image lag) to investigate the degree to which the NPS is reduced by such correlation. For first-frame image lag of approximately 5-8%, the NPS is reduced by approximately 20% compared to the lag-free case. A simple model is presented that results in an approximate rule of thumb for computing the effect of image lag on NPS under conditions of spatiotemporal separability. The volumetric NPS of cone-beam CT images is analyzed under varying conditions of spatial correlation, controlled by adjustment of the reconstruction filter. The volumetric NPS is found to be highly asymmetric, exhibiting a ramp characteristic in transverse planes (typical of filtered back-rojection) and a band-limited characteristic in the longitudinal direction (resulting from low-pass characteristics of the imager). Such asymmetry could have implications regarding the detectability of structures visualized in transverse versus sagittal or coronal planes. In all cases, appreciation of the full dimensionality of the image data is essential to obtaining meaningful NPS results. The framework may be applied to NPS analysis of image data of arbitrary dimensionality provided the system satisfies conditions of NPS existence.
提出了一种用于多维图像噪声功率谱(NPS)实验分析的方法框架,该框架采用了n维(nD)傅里叶变换的著名特性。该方法被推广到n维,在n = 1(例如,时间序列)和n = 2(例如,投影放射成像)的情况下简化为熟悉的情形,并针对n = 3的两种情况进行了实验验证(即,分别使用有源矩阵平板成像器进行x射线荧光透视和锥束CT在时空域和体积域中形成三维(3D)图像)。完全nD NPS分析与用于分析NPS“中心切片”的各种技术之间的关系以一种直接适用于测量的nD数据的方式进行了阐述,突出了相关性的影响,并使NPS归一化问题变得透明。在不同的时间相关性(图像滞后)条件下分析荧光透视图像的时空NPS,以研究这种相关性使NPS降低的程度。对于大约5 - 8%的首帧图像滞后,与无滞后情况相比,NPS降低了约20%。提出了一个简单模型,该模型得出了一个近似经验法则,用于在时空可分离性条件下计算图像滞后对NPS的影响。在通过调整重建滤波器控制的不同空间相关性条件下分析锥束CT图像的体积NPS。发现体积NPS高度不对称,在横向平面呈现斜坡特性(典型的滤波反投影),在纵向呈现带限特性(由成像器的低通特性导致)。这种不对称可能对在横向与矢状面或冠状面中可视化结构的可检测性产生影响。在所有情况下,认识到图像数据的全维度对于获得有意义的NPS结果至关重要。只要系统满足NPS存在的条件,该框架可应用于任意维度图像数据的NPS分析。