Goodwin Mel, Wade David, Luke Barbara, Davies Paul
Department of Neurology, Northampton General Hospital NHS Trust, Cliftonville, Northampton, UK.
Seizure. 2002 Dec;11(8):519-22. doi: 10.1016/s1059-1311(02)00132-2.
The management of a group of epilepsy patients from primary care, in a geographical area with clear epilepsy management guidelines and secondary care clinics is surveyed. Suggestions are made to improve liaison between primary and secondary care as well as epilepsy management in primary care. All 42 local primary care practices were invited to take part in this project. A study day providing a broad overview of epilepsy management was held. Those attending were expected to identify all patients in their practice with epilepsy using diagnostic codes and prescribing data. Nine of the invited 42 practices took part in the project, and identified 506 patients prescribed anti-epilepsy drugs (AEDs). Three hundred and three patients were invited for review by their practice nurse, following exclusion of those prescribed AEDs for other conditions, children and those already under specialist review. One hundred and sixteen patients attended for review. Seventy-one patients were identified as requiring specialist review and a consultant neurologist, epilepsy nurse specialist and clinical assistant completed them. Of the 71 patients 31 had experienced no seizures for 5 years, 40 had experienced seizures in the past 5 years, of whom 32 had experienced seizures in the last year. Sixteen were suffering at least one seizure per month, and a few had poorly controlled epilepsy. Patients were taking mainly Phenytoin, Carbamazepine and Sodium valproate. Twenty were taking polytherapy and one no treatment.Fifty-two patients reported side effects and 15 poor compliance. Many patients reviewed were considered to be taking unnecessary medication and suffering unnecessary side effects. There is a need for improved epilepsy management in primary care and better liaison between primary and secondary care.
在一个有明确癫痫管理指南且设有二级护理诊所的地理区域内,对一组来自基层医疗的癫痫患者的管理情况进行了调查。针对改善基层医疗与二级医疗之间的联络以及基层医疗中的癫痫管理提出了建议。邀请了当地所有42家基层医疗诊所参与该项目。举办了一个对癫痫管理进行全面概述的研究日活动。预计参会人员会利用诊断编码和处方数据来识别其诊所内所有癫痫患者。受邀的42家诊所中有9家参与了该项目,并识别出506名正在服用抗癫痫药物(AEDs)的患者。在排除因其他病症服用AEDs的患者、儿童以及那些已在接受专科检查的患者后,303名患者被邀请由其诊所护士进行复查。116名患者前来接受复查。71名患者被确定需要专科复查,由一名神经科顾问医生、癫痫专科护士和临床助理完成了复查。在这71名患者中,31名已经5年没有发作,40名在过去5年中有发作,其中32名在去年有发作。16名患者每月至少发作一次,少数患者癫痫控制不佳。患者主要服用苯妥英钠、卡马西平和丙戊酸钠。20名患者接受联合治疗,1名未接受治疗。52名患者报告有副作用,15名患者依从性差。许多接受复查的患者被认为正在服用不必要的药物并遭受不必要的副作用。基层医疗中需要改善癫痫管理,基层医疗与二级医疗之间需要更好的联络。