Adair Robert K
Department of Physics, Yale University, New Haven, Connecticut 06520-8121, USA.
Bioelectromagnetics. 2003 Jan;24(1):39-48. doi: 10.1002/bem.10061.
Using biophysical criteria, I show that continuous radiofrequency (RF) and microwave radiation with intensity less than 10 mW/cm(2) are unlikely to affect physiology significantly through athermal mechanisms. Biological systems are fundamentally noisy on the molecular scale as a consequence of thermal agitation and are noisy macroscopically as a consequence of physiological functions and animal behavior. If electromagnetic fields are to significantly affect physiology, their direct physical effect must be greater than that from the ubiquitous endogenous noise. Using that criterion, I show that none of a set of interactions of weak fields, which I argue is nearly complete on dimensional grounds, can affect biology on the molecular scale. Moreover, I conclude that such weak fields are quite unlikely to generate significant effects in their interactions with larger biological elements such as cells. In the course of that analysis, I examine important special examples of electromagnetic interactions: "direct" interactions where biology is modified simply by the motion of charged elements generated by the electric field; resonance interactions; the effects of electrostrictive forces and induced dipole moments; and modifications of radical pair recombination probabilities. In each case, I show that it is unlikely that low intensity fields can generate significant physiological consequences.
运用生物物理标准,我证明强度小于10毫瓦/平方厘米的连续射频(RF)和微波辐射不太可能通过非热机制对生理产生显著影响。由于热搅动,生物系统在分子尺度上本质上是有噪声的,并且由于生理功能和动物行为,在宏观上也是有噪声的。如果电磁场要显著影响生理,其直接物理效应必须大于普遍存在的内源性噪声的影响。基于该标准,我证明了一组弱场相互作用(我认为从维度角度来看这几乎是完整的)中没有一种能够在分子尺度上影响生物学。此外,我得出结论,这种弱场在与诸如细胞等较大生物元件相互作用时极不可能产生显著影响。在该分析过程中,我研究了电磁相互作用的重要特殊例子:“直接”相互作用,即生物学仅通过电场产生的带电元件的运动而被改变;共振相互作用;电致伸缩力和感应偶极矩的影响;以及自由基对复合概率的改变。在每种情况下,我都表明低强度场不太可能产生显著的生理后果。