Govind J, King W, Bailey B, Bogduk N
Department of Clinical Research, University of Newcastle, Royal Newcastle Hospital, Newcastle NSW 2300, Australia.
J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry. 2003 Jan;74(1):88-93. doi: 10.1136/jnnp.74.1.88.
To evaluate the efficacy of a revised technique of percutaneous radiofrequency neurotomy for third occipital headache.
The revisions included using a large gauge electrode, ensuring minimum separation between the three electrode placements, and holding the electrode in place by hand. The revised technique was used to treat 51 nerves in 49 patients diagnosed as suffering from third occipital headache on the basis of controlled diagnostic blocks of the third occipital nerve. The criteria for successful outcome were complete relief of pain for at least 90 days associated with restoration of normal activities of daily living, and no use of drug treatment for the headache.
Of the 49 patients, 43 (88%) achieved a successful outcome. The median duration of relief in these patients was 297 days, with eight patients continuing to have ongoing relief. Fourteen patients underwent a repeat neurotomy to reinstate relief, with 12 (86%) achieving a successful outcome. The median duration of relief in these patients was 217 days, with six patients having ongoing relief. Side effects of the procedure were consistent with coagulation of the third occipital nerve and consisted of slight ataxia, numbness, and temporary dysaesthesia. No side effects required intervention, and they were tolerated by the patients in exchange for the relief of headache.
Use of the revised procedure greatly improved the rather low success rate previously encountered with third occipital neurotomy. Although the relief of headache is limited in duration, it is profound and can be reinstated by repeat neurotomy. No other form of treatment has been validated for this common form of headache.
评估改良经皮射频神经切断术治疗枕大神经痛的疗效。
改良措施包括使用大号电极、确保三个电极放置点之间的距离最小以及用手固定电极。改良技术用于治疗49例经枕大神经诊断性阻滞确诊为枕大神经痛的患者的51条神经。成功的标准是疼痛完全缓解至少90天,同时恢复正常日常生活活动,且无需使用药物治疗头痛。
49例患者中,43例(88%)取得成功。这些患者缓解的中位持续时间为297天,8例患者持续缓解。14例患者接受了重复神经切断术以恢复缓解,其中12例(86%)取得成功。这些患者缓解的中位持续时间为217天,6例患者持续缓解。该手术的副作用与枕大神经凝固一致,包括轻微共济失调、麻木和短暂感觉异常。无需对副作用进行干预,患者为缓解头痛而耐受这些副作用。
使用改良手术大大提高了先前枕大神经切断术较低的成功率。尽管头痛缓解的持续时间有限,但程度较深,可通过重复神经切断术恢复。对于这种常见的头痛形式,尚无其他形式的治疗方法得到验证。