Rathore Saif S, Ordin Diana L, Krumholz Harlan M
Section of Cardiovascular Medicine, Department of Internal Medicine, Yale University School of Medicine, New Haven, Conn 06520-8025, USA.
Am Heart J. 2002 Dec;144(6):1052-6. doi: 10.1067/mhj.2002.126122.
Prior studies have reported race and sex differences in cardiac catheterization use after acute myocardial infarction (AMI). It is unclear whether race or sex differences in procedure refusal may contribute to this difference. We sought to determine whether cardiac catheterization refusal rates differ by patient race or sex.
We evaluated medical records of 74,745 Medicare beneficiaries hospitalized for AMI between January 1994 and February 1996 to ascertain refusal of cardiac catheterization during hospitalization. Patient race and sex were evaluated for their association with cardiac catheterization refusal adjusting for patient, physician, and hospital characteristics.
The cardiac catheterization refusal rate in the overall cohort was 2.92% (95% CI 2.80%-3.04%). Race and sex differences in cardiac catheterization were observed after multivariate adjustment, with white women (odds ratio [OR] 1.28), black men (OR 1.34), and black women (OR 1.37) more likely to refuse cardiac catheterization than white men (OR 1.00). Relative differences in refusal were associated with only modest absolute differences in risk-standardized rates of cardiac catheterization refusal; rates were lowest for white men (2.55%), and higher for white women (3.21%), black men (3.36%), and black women (3.38%, P <.001 for global comparison).
Patient race and sex were associated with cardiac catheterization refusal among elderly patients hospitalized with AMI. However, absolute race and sex differences in rates of procedure refusal were small, suggesting that race and sex differences in cardiac catheterization refusal provide only a partial explanation of observed differences in cardiac procedure use.
先前的研究报道了急性心肌梗死(AMI)后心脏导管插入术使用方面的种族和性别差异。尚不清楚在手术拒绝方面的种族或性别差异是否导致了这种差异。我们试图确定心脏导管插入术的拒绝率是否因患者种族或性别而异。
我们评估了1994年1月至1996年2月期间因AMI住院的74745名医疗保险受益人的病历,以确定住院期间是否拒绝心脏导管插入术。评估患者种族和性别与心脏导管插入术拒绝之间的关联,并对患者、医生和医院特征进行调整。
整个队列中的心脏导管插入术拒绝率为2.92%(95%可信区间2.80%-3.04%)。多变量调整后观察到心脏导管插入术存在种族和性别差异,白人女性(优势比[OR]1.28)、黑人男性(OR 1.34)和黑人女性(OR 1.37)比白人男性(OR 1.00)更有可能拒绝心脏导管插入术。拒绝的相对差异仅与心脏导管插入术拒绝的风险标准化率中的适度绝对差异相关;白人男性的比率最低(2.55%),白人女性(3.21%)、黑人男性(3.36%)和黑人女性(3.38%,总体比较P<.001)的比率较高。
在因AMI住院的老年患者中,患者种族和性别与心脏导管插入术拒绝相关。然而,手术拒绝率的绝对种族和性别差异较小,这表明心脏导管插入术拒绝方面的种族和性别差异仅部分解释了观察到的心脏手术使用差异。