Roberts Catherine C, McDaniel N Troy, Krupinski Elizabeth A, Erly William K
Department of Radiology, University of Arizona Health Sciences Center, Tucson, Arizona, USA.
Spine (Phila Pa 1976). 2003 Jan 15;28(2):167-70. doi: 10.1097/00007632-200301150-00013.
Cervical spine computed tomograms were evaluated for neural foraminal stenosis in both the standard axial plane and the oblique reformatted plane.
To assess whether oblique reformation of cervical spine computed tomograms reduces interobserver variability in the evaluation of neural foraminal stenosis.
Radiographic assessment of neural foraminal stenosis is subjective, may vary among observers, and can affect surgical planning.
The cervical spine images from 19 patients with various degrees of neural foraminal stenosis were reformatted in an oblique plane perpendicular to the long axis of the right and left neural foramens. Seven independent observers graded the degree of foraminal stenosis (none, mild [1-25%], moderate [26-75%], or severe [>75%]) and their confidence level (definite, probable, possible) on both the axial images and the oblique reformations.
The ages of the 12 male (mean, 67.5 +/- 13.24 years) and 7 female (mean, 62.7 +/- 14.79 years) patients ranged from 39 to 83 years. Interobserver variability was assessed with chi2 analysis. Rates of agreement on degree of stenosis (chi2 = 19.94; df= 9; P< 0.02) were significantly higher for oblique reformations. Confidence ratings also were significantly higher for oblique reformations (chi2 = 18.19; df= 7; P< 0.02).
Oblique reformation of cervical spine images significantly reduces the degree of interobserver variability and increases observer confidence in the assessment of neural foraminal stenosis. Oblique reformations should be considered in the routine evaluation of neural foraminal stenosis.
对颈椎计算机断层扫描图像在标准轴向平面和斜位重组平面进行神经孔狭窄评估。
评估颈椎计算机断层扫描图像的斜位重组是否能减少观察者间在神经孔狭窄评估中的变异性。
神经孔狭窄的影像学评估具有主观性,观察者之间可能存在差异,且会影响手术规划。
对19例不同程度神经孔狭窄患者的颈椎图像进行斜位重组,使其垂直于左右神经孔的长轴。7名独立观察者对轴向图像和斜位重组图像上的神经孔狭窄程度(无、轻度[1 - 25%]、中度[26 - 75%]或重度[>75%])及其信心水平(确定、可能、有可能)进行分级。
12例男性(平均年龄67.5±13.24岁)和7例女性(平均年龄62.7±14.79岁)患者的年龄在39至83岁之间。采用卡方分析评估观察者间变异性。斜位重组图像在狭窄程度的一致性率(卡方 = 19.94;自由度 = 9;P < 0.02)显著更高。斜位重组图像的信心评级也显著更高(卡方 = 18.19;自由度 = 7;P < 0.02)。
颈椎图像的斜位重组显著降低了观察者间变异性程度,并提高了观察者对神经孔狭窄评估的信心。在神经孔狭窄的常规评估中应考虑斜位重组。