Oliveri Roberto S, Wille-Jørgensen Peer A, Thorup Jens F
Klinisk biokemisk afdeling KB 3011, H:S Rigshospitalet, DK-2100 København ø.
Ugeskr Laeger. 2003 Jan 13;165(3):229-32.
Denmark has no tradition of formal assessment of junior doctors' theoretical knowledge. We therefore wanted to investigate whether the knowledge of surgical junior doctors has actually increased.
Twenty-three junior doctors were confronted with the same multiple-choice questionnaires twice during a six months period. Subsequently, they were asked whether they would approve the implementation of multiple-choice questionnaires and formal assessment (exam) in the Danish specialist training in surgery.
The participants got a significantly higher score the second time they were confronted with the multiple-choice questionnaires (p = 0.0003). When dividing the participants into two groups, viz. young vs. old junior doctors, it was observed that the latter group had a higher score overall but augmented their scores less in relation to their young colleagues (p = 0.038). Forty percent of the participants replied that the multiple-choice questionnaires had motivated them to do further theoretical studies, and half of them approved the introduction of an exam in surgery in the Danish specialist training.
The theoretical knowledge of junior doctors does actually increase in a relatively short period of time during their employment at a department of surgery. As expected the old junior doctors got a higher score compared to their young colleagues. However, the latter group augments its knowledge relatively more. Multiple-choice questionnaires are easy, accessible, and inexpensive tools for evaluation as well as stimulation for doing further theroretical studies.
丹麦没有对初级医生理论知识进行正式评估的传统。因此,我们想调查外科初级医生的知识是否真的有所增加。
23名初级医生在六个月内两次面对相同的多项选择题问卷。随后,他们被问及是否赞成在丹麦外科专科培训中实施多项选择题问卷和正式评估(考试)。
参与者第二次面对多项选择题问卷时得分显著更高(p = 0.0003)。将参与者分为两组,即年轻初级医生与年长初级医生,结果发现后一组总体得分更高,但与年轻同事相比,其分数增长幅度较小(p = 0.038)。40%的参与者回答说多项选择题问卷促使他们进一步进行理论学习,其中一半人赞成在丹麦专科培训中引入外科考试。
初级医生的理论知识在其受雇于外科科室的相对较短时间内确实有所增加。正如预期的那样,年长的初级医生比年轻同事得分更高。然而,年轻组的知识增长相对更多。多项选择题问卷是用于评估以及激励进一步进行理论学习的简便、易获取且成本低廉的工具。