William David E, Bailey George S, Reddy Ashok, Hendricks Jerry D, Oganesian Aram, Orner Gayle A, Pereira Cliff B, Swenberg James A
Marine Freshwater Biomedical Sciences Center, Oregon State University, Corvallis, Oregon, USA.
Toxicol Pathol. 2003 Jan-Feb;31 Suppl:58-61.
The rainbow trout has been utilized as a model for human carcinogenesis for a number of years. Trout are relatively inexpensive to maintain and exhibit (over the 9-12-month tumor assay period) very low spontaneous tumor backgrounds. One of the most powerful applications of this model is the design and conduct of large-scale tumor studies requiring thousands of animals that address statistically challenging questions of dose-response. Two recent examples of such applications include our studies on I3C as a tumor promoter and DBP as a tumor initiator. I3C was shown to promote AFB1-initiated liver cancer at doses near those recommended for supplementation in humans. Further studies are required to determine if the mechanisms responsible for promotion in trout can be extrapolated to humans. In the second example, we report results from the largest animal tumor study ever conducted. A total of 42,000 trout were utilized to measure DBP carcinogenesis down to incidences of 1 in 5,000. The dose response model deviated significantly from linearity although the existence of a threshold could not be statistically established. Extrapolation of the data model predicts a DBP dose producing 1 in 10(6) cancers that is 1,000-fold higher than predicted by the conservative linear model. If these results can be confirmed with other carcinogens (genotoxic and perhaps nongenotoxic) and other targets, this could have a significant impact on the utilization of animal tumor data in human risk assessment.
多年来,虹鳟鱼一直被用作人类致癌作用的模型。饲养虹鳟鱼成本相对较低,并且(在9至12个月的肿瘤检测期内)自发肿瘤背景极低。该模型最强大的应用之一是设计和开展大规模肿瘤研究,这类研究需要数千只动物,以解决剂量反应方面具有统计学挑战性的问题。此类应用的两个近期实例包括我们关于I3C作为肿瘤促进剂和DBP作为肿瘤启动剂的研究。结果表明,I3C在接近人类推荐补充剂量的情况下可促进黄曲霉毒素B1引发的肝癌。需要进一步研究以确定虹鳟鱼中促进肿瘤发生的机制是否可外推至人类。在第二个实例中,我们报告了有史以来规模最大的动物肿瘤研究结果。总共使用了42,000条虹鳟鱼来测定DBP致癌作用,低至每5000条鱼中有1条发病。剂量反应模型明显偏离线性,尽管无法通过统计学确定阈值的存在。数据模型外推预测产生十万分之一癌症的DBP剂量比保守线性模型预测的高1000倍。如果这些结果能够在其他致癌物(遗传毒性以及可能的非遗传毒性致癌物)和其他靶标中得到证实,这可能会对动物肿瘤数据在人类风险评估中的应用产生重大影响。