Thomas Cindy Parks, Wallack Stanley S, Lee Sue, McCarty Dennis, Swift Robert
Schneider Institute for Health Policy, Brandeis University, Heller Graduate School MS035, 415 South Street, Waltham, MA 02454-9110, USA.
J Subst Abuse Treat. 2003 Jan;24(1):1-11.
Naltrexone, a prescription medication, was approved in December 1994 as an adjunct to counseling in treatment of alcoholism and alcohol abuse, representing the first new medication for alcoholism in several decades. Initial controlled trials indicated that it is effective in preventing relapse, while later trials show mixed results. Although many physicians and others treating alcoholism have found naltrexone to be very helpful in treatment, it is still a technology that has not been used widely. In this study, we examine which clinicians have adopted naltrexone into practice for what reasons, and what clinical and nonclinical factors acted as barriers to its use. In our mail survey of alcoholism treatment clinicians, 80% of physicians and 45% of nonphysicians report prescribing or recommending naltrexone at least rarely, but only 15% of physicians, even among addiction specialists, prescribe naltrexone often. The strongest barriers to adoption of naltrexone were financing and inadequate knowledge about the medication, followed by lack of sufficient evidence regarding effectiveness. Clinicians were most likely to adopt naltrexone if they were affiliated with treatment programs that actively promoted its use. We conclude that in order for a new substance abuse treatment medication to be widely adopted in clinical practice, information about it must be properly directed, clinicians must be convinced of its effectiveness, it must be adequately financed, and the treatment organizations in which clinicians work must promote its use.
纳曲酮是一种处方药,于1994年12月被批准作为治疗酗酒和酒精滥用的咨询辅助药物,是几十年来第一种用于治疗酗酒的新药。最初的对照试验表明它在预防复发方面有效,而后来的试验结果则喜忧参半。尽管许多治疗酗酒的医生和其他人发现纳曲酮在治疗中非常有帮助,但它仍然是一种尚未被广泛使用的技术。在这项研究中,我们调查了哪些临床医生出于何种原因在实践中采用了纳曲酮,以及哪些临床和非临床因素阻碍了它的使用。在我们对酗酒治疗临床医生的邮件调查中,80%的医生和45%的非医生报告至少偶尔会开出处方或推荐使用纳曲酮,但即使在成瘾专家中,也只有15%的医生经常开纳曲酮。采用纳曲酮的最大障碍是资金问题和对该药物的了解不足,其次是缺乏关于其有效性的充分证据。如果临床医生隶属于积极推广使用纳曲酮的治疗项目,他们最有可能采用该药物。我们得出结论,为了使一种新的药物滥用治疗药物在临床实践中得到广泛应用,必须对其信息进行正确引导,临床医生必须相信其有效性,必须有足够的资金支持,并且临床医生工作的治疗机构必须推广其使用。