Gottheil E, Thornton C C, Exline R V
Arch Gen Psychiatry. 1976 May;33(5):565-8. doi: 10.1001/archpsyc.1976.01770050033004.
The hypothesis that normal subjects can express emotions more accurately than schizophrenics was tested by having judges match photographs of five posed affects with five emotion words for each of 16 normal and 16 schizophrenic male expressors. Discrimination accuracy was high, but the hypothesis was not confirmed. The results of a second study, in which separate measures of appropriate (intended) and "background" affect (eg, the rated intensity of anger displayed in a subject's nonangry poses) were provided, supported our expectation that discrimination accuracy is a function of both appropriate and background affect. The normal men tended to display more appropriate affect generally, and displayed more background happiness, while the schizophrenics expressed more background anger, sadness, and fear. Both intended and background affect, therefore, must be carefully considered in studies of emotional expressions.
通过让评判者将16名正常男性表达者和16名精神分裂症男性表达者的五张摆拍表情照片与五个情感词汇进行匹配,来检验正常受试者比精神分裂症患者能更准确地表达情感这一假设。辨别准确率很高,但该假设未得到证实。在第二项研究中,分别给出了恰当(有意的)情感和“背景”情感的测量结果(例如,受试者非愤怒表情中所表现出的愤怒程度评分),这一研究结果支持了我们的预期,即辨别准确率是恰当情感和背景情感两者的函数。正常男性总体上倾向于表现出更恰当的情感,且表现出更多的背景性愉悦,而精神分裂症患者则表现出更多的背景性愤怒、悲伤和恐惧。因此,在情感表达研究中,必须仔细考虑有意情感和背景情感两者。