Dota Corina D, Edvardsson Nils, Schützer Kajs-Marie, Olofsson Eva Lavik, Malm Anders, Morsing Tomas, Fager Gunnar
AstraZeneca R&D, Mölndal, S-431 83 Mölndal, Sweden.
Pacing Clin Electrophysiol. 2003 Jan;26(1P2):361-6. doi: 10.1046/j.1460-9592.2003.00050.x.
The ECG may vary during the day (intra-day), and between days (interday), for the same subject. Variability in ECG characteristic measurements between different investigators is well documented and is often large. During days 1-6 of each placebo period of a two-way crossover Phase I study, digital ECGs were recorded at about 8 and 12 AM in 16 healthy volunteers (8 men, 8 women). Two observers independently analyzed leads V2 and V6 using EClysis software. The durations and amplitudes of major ECG waves and the intervals between major electrocardiographic events were analyzed in a mixed model ANOVA, in which subject, observer, time, and day were treated as random factors. The influence of various corrections for heart rate on the variability of QT intervals was investigated. The difference among subjects explained between 44-81% of the total variability in ECG intervals and amplitudes. Overall, inter- and intraday variability was not statistically significant for any variable. The individualized exponential correction of the QT interval for heart rate eliminated the QT interval dependence on the RR interval in all subjects. Changes in T wave morphology and shortening of the QT interval from morning to noon were observed in ten subjects. The interobserver variability was close to zero (SD < 0.005 ms) for all variables except the PQ interval (SD 1.4 ms). The various sources of variability in determinations of ECG wave characteristics should be considered in the design of clinical studies. The use of EClysis software for ECG measurements is this study made the results highly observer independent.
对于同一受试者,心电图在一天内(日内)以及不同日期之间(日间)可能会有所不同。不同研究者之间心电图特征测量的变异性已有充分记录,且通常较大。在一项双向交叉I期研究的每个安慰剂期的第1 - 6天,于上午8点左右和12点记录了16名健康志愿者(8名男性,8名女性)的数字心电图。两名观察者使用EClysis软件独立分析V2和V6导联。在一个混合模型方差分析中分析了主要心电图波的持续时间和振幅以及主要心电图事件之间的间期,其中将受试者、观察者、时间和日期视为随机因素。研究了各种心率校正对QT间期变异性的影响。受试者之间的差异解释了心电图间期和振幅总变异性的44% - 81%。总体而言,任何变量的日间和日内变异性均无统计学意义。针对心率对QT间期进行个体化指数校正消除了所有受试者中QT间期对RR间期的依赖性。在10名受试者中观察到T波形态的变化以及QT间期从早晨到中午的缩短。除PQ间期(标准差1.4毫秒)外,所有变量的观察者间变异性均接近零(标准差<0.005毫秒)。在临床研究设计中应考虑心电图波特征测定中变异性的各种来源。本研究中使用EClysis软件进行心电图测量使得结果高度独立于观察者。