Martin-de las Heras Stella, Valenzuela Aurora, Bellini Renzo, Salas Carlos, Rubiño Manuel, Garcia Jose Antonio
Department of Forensic Odontology, College of Medicine and Odontology, University of Granada, 18071 Granada, Spain.
Forensic Sci Int. 2003 Mar 12;132(1):57-62. doi: 10.1016/s0379-0738(02)00454-1.
Age-related changes in tooth color have been described previously, however, the use of dental color for age estimation in forensic odontology has been limited due to the difficulty of measuring color objectively. This study presents an objective method for determining dental color to estimate the age of an individual. Dentine color in 250 teeth from patients ranging in age from 10 to 89 years was determined by spectroradiometry. Color measurements were performed as suggested in the CIE 1931 (International Commission on Illumination). Chromaticity coordinates (x, y, z), luminance (Y), whiteness index (WIC, Z%, WIC) and yellowness index (YI) were obtained. Correlations between these colorimetric variables and aging were established by linear regression analyses. All the variables fit the mathematical model with correlation coefficients ranging from 0.53 to 0.75. This method of color measurement produced an expected associated error of calibration averaging 13.7 years about the mean estimated values, at a 70% level of confidence. Two different multiple regression models for dental age estimation were tested, and variables that made the greatest contributions to age calculation were identified. To determine the effect of postmortem interval on tooth color and its influence in age estimation, 37 teeth obtained from human skeletal remains buried during an interval ranging from 21 to 37 years were also studied. In this material, the correlation between age and dental color measured by spectroradiometry was weaker than in fresh extracted teeth. It is concluded that determination of dentine color by spectroradiometry is a potentially useful objective method to estimate age in forensic studies in combination with other methods.
先前已有关于牙齿颜色随年龄变化的描述,然而,由于客观测量颜色存在困难,法医牙科学中利用牙齿颜色估计年龄的应用一直有限。本研究提出了一种确定牙齿颜色以估计个体年龄的客观方法。通过分光辐射度法测定了年龄在10至89岁之间的患者的250颗牙齿的牙本质颜色。按照国际照明委员会(CIE)1931的建议进行颜色测量。获得了色度坐标(x、y、z)、亮度(Y)、白度指数(WIC、Z%、WIC)和黄度指数(YI)。通过线性回归分析建立了这些比色变量与衰老之间的相关性。所有变量均符合数学模型,相关系数范围为0.53至0.75。这种颜色测量方法在70%的置信水平下,校准的预期相关误差平均约为估计平均值的13.7年。测试了两种不同的用于牙齿年龄估计的多元回归模型,并确定了对年龄计算贡献最大的变量。为了确定死后时间间隔对牙齿颜色的影响及其在年龄估计中的作用,还研究了从埋葬时间间隔为21至37年的人类骨骼遗骸中获取的37颗牙齿。在这种材料中,通过分光辐射度法测量的年龄与牙齿颜色之间的相关性比新鲜拔除的牙齿中要弱。得出的结论是,在法医研究中,结合其他方法,通过分光辐射度法测定牙本质颜色是一种潜在有用的估计年龄的客观方法。