Carroll Aaron E, Tarczy-Hornoch Peter, O'Reilly Eamon, Christakis Dimitri A
Robert Wood Johnson Clinical Scholars Program, University of Washington, Seattle, Washington 98195-7183, USA.
Pediatrics. 2003 May;111(5 Pt 1):976-80. doi: 10.1542/peds.111.5.976.
Medical errors are common and potentially dangerous. Little is known about the role of documentation errors.
To determine the proportion of resident physician progress notes that contained discrepancies, and to identify predictors of such discrepancies.
DESIGN/METHODS: We conducted a retrospective cross-sectional chart review of resident physician progress notes over 40 random days in a 4-month period in a neonatal intensive care unit. Using predetermined criteria, we compared resident documentation of patient weights, medications, and vascular lines to other sources of information and recorded the numbers of documentation discrepancies.
There were discrepancies in 209 (61.7%) notes with respect to weight, vascular lines, or medications. Discrepancies occurred in the documentation of medications in 103 (27.7%) progress notes, of vascular lines in 119 (33.9%) progress notes, and of weights in 45 (13.3%) progress notes. Notes both omitted information regarding medications (18.2%) and vascular lines (13.9%) and documented inaccurate information regarding medications (18.6%) and vascular lines (30.1%). Patients with more medications or vascular lines, and with longer lengths of stay, were significantly more likely to have higher rates of documentation errors.
Daily progress notes written by resident physicians in the neonatal intensive care unit often contain inaccurate, or omit pertinent, information. Alternative means or methods of documentation are warranted.
医疗差错很常见且具有潜在危险性。关于文件记录差错的作用,人们了解甚少。
确定住院医师病程记录中存在差异的比例,并识别此类差异的预测因素。
设计/方法:我们对新生儿重症监护病房4个月内随机抽取的40天的住院医师病程记录进行了回顾性横断面图表审查。使用预先确定的标准,我们将住院医师记录的患者体重、用药情况和血管通路与其他信息来源进行比较,并记录文件记录差异的数量。
在209份(61.7%)记录中,体重、血管通路或用药情况存在差异。103份(27.7%)病程记录中用药情况的记录存在差异,119份(33.9%)病程记录中血管通路的记录存在差异,45份(13.3%)病程记录中体重的记录存在差异。记录既遗漏了用药情况(18.2%)和血管通路(13.9%)的信息,也记录了用药情况(18.6%)和血管通路(30.1%)的不准确信息。用药或血管通路更多、住院时间更长的患者,文件记录错误率显著更高。
新生儿重症监护病房住院医师书写的每日病程记录常常包含不准确或遗漏相关信息的情况。有必要采用其他记录方式或方法。