Goto Yoichi, Itoh Haruki, Adachi Hitoshi, Ueshima Kenji, Nohara Ryuji
Division of Cardiology, National Cardiovascular Center, Suita, Osaka, Japan.
Circ J. 2003 May;67(5):411-5. doi: 10.1253/circj.67.411.
The purpose of this study was to determine the rate of participation of patients after acute myocardial infarction (AMI) in phase II cardiac rehabilitation with exercise training (ie, exercise cardiac rehabilitation, ECR) in Japan. Forty-six hospitals treating patients with AMI were surveyed for their implementation of phase II ECR after AMI in 1996-98. Of the 46 hospitals, 19 were approved and 27 were not approved for health insurance payment for ECR. A total of 13685 patients with AMI were admitted to the 46 hospitals. There were no differences between approved and non-approved hospitals in the annual number of patients with AMI (Approved, 117+61 vs Non-approved, 86+71 patients per hospital, NS), the rate of performance of emergency coronary angioplasty (63+16 vs 65+20%, NS), or the rate of emergency coronary stenting (31+16 vs 34+22%, NS). However, ECR was performed routinely in 84.2% (16/19 hospitals) of the approved hospitals, but in only 22.2% (6/27 hospitals) of the non-approved hospitals (p<0.001). Although the participation rate of AMI patients in ECR was 21.0% (2875/13685 patients) overall, it was markedly lower in the non-approved hospitals (8.0%, 557/6999 patients) than in the approved hospitals (34.7%, 2318/6686 patients, p<0.0001). Based on the present result, the overall rate of participation of AMI patients in ECR in Japan was estimated at 4.8-11.7%. Despite similar patient volumes and acute phase interventional treatment of AMI between the hospitals approved and not approved for health insurance payment for ECR, ECR was markedly underused in the non-approved hospitals in Japan. To promote ECR for all AMI patients in Japan, the number of hospitals approved for ECR should be substantially increased.
本研究的目的是确定日本急性心肌梗死(AMI)患者参与二期心脏康复运动训练(即运动心脏康复,ECR)的比例。对46家治疗AMI患者的医院进行了调查,了解其在1996 - 1998年期间AMI后实施二期ECR的情况。在这46家医院中,19家获得了ECR医疗保险支付批准,27家未获批准。46家医院共收治了13685例AMI患者。在AMI患者的年收治数量(获批准医院,每家医院117 + 61例 vs 未获批准医院,每家医院86 + 71例,无统计学差异)、急诊冠状动脉血管成形术的实施率(63 + 16% vs 65 + 20%,无统计学差异)或急诊冠状动脉支架置入率(31 + 16% vs 34 + 22%,无统计学差异)方面,获批准医院和未获批准医院之间没有差异。然而,84.2%(16/19家医院)的获批准医院常规开展ECR,而未获批准医院中只有22.2%(6/27家医院)开展ECR(p < 0.001)。尽管AMI患者参与ECR的总体比例为21.0%(2875/13685例患者),但在未获批准医院中这一比例(8.0%,557/6999例患者)明显低于获批准医院(34.7%,