Schémann J F, Banou A, Malvy D, Guindo A, Traore L, Momo G
Institute of African Tropical Ophthalmology (IOTA), BP 248 Bamako, Mali.
Public Health Nutr. 2003 May;6(3):233-44. doi: 10.1079/PHN2002432.
The impact on vitamin A status of the distribution of vitamin A during national immunisation days (NIDs) has not been well established despite strong promotion by international agencies and donors. Using a pre-post design, the change in prevalence of vitamin A deficiency was examined in pre-school children in Mali.
Two cross-sectional surveys were conducted in Mopti region, the first in March 1997 before this strategy was adopted and the second in March 1999, four-and-a-half months after a mass distribution of vitamin A during NIDs.
We compared the vitamin A status of children aged 12 to 66 months targeted in 1999 by NIDs with the status of children in the same age group in 1997. Infectious events of the previous two weeks were concurrently recorded. Within the 1999 sample, the status of recipient and non-recipient children was also compared.
In 1997, the prevalence of xerophthalmia (defined by the presence of night blindness and/or Bitot spots) was 6.9% (95% confidence interval (CI) 5.1-9.2) and the modified retinol dose response (MRDR) test proved abnormal in 77.8% of 12-66-month-old children (95% CI 68.27-85.17). In 1999 this picture had improved significantly, both for xerophthalmia prevalence, 3.3% (95% CI 2.1-5.2), and abnormal MRDR test response, 63.1% (95% CI 54.25-71.23). The infectious morbidity rates between 1997 and 1999 tended to decrease. No significant improvement was found among children older than those targeted by NIDs. In 1999, children who received vitamin A had a lower risk for xerophthalmia (3.0% for recipients vs. 8.7% for non-recipients) and experienced fewer infectious events.
The clinical and biological vitamin A status of pre-school children improved between 1997 and 1999. Mass distribution of vitamin A appears to reduce the occurrence of xerophthalmia and would seem to be associated with a decrease in other related illnesses. Vitamin A supplementation during NIDs should be given a high priority when vitamin A deficiency remains a public health problem.
尽管国际机构和捐助者大力推广,但国家免疫日(NIDs)期间维生素A的分发对维生素A状况的影响尚未得到充分证实。采用前后设计,对马里学龄前儿童维生素A缺乏症患病率的变化进行了研究。
在莫普提地区进行了两次横断面调查,第一次在1997年3月该策略采用之前,第二次在1999年3月,即在国家免疫日大规模分发维生素A四个半月之后。
我们比较了1999年国家免疫日针对的12至66个月大儿童的维生素A状况与1997年同年龄组儿童的状况。同时记录了前两周的感染事件。在1999年的样本中,还比较了接受者和未接受者儿童的状况。
1997年,干眼症(由夜盲症和/或毕脱氏斑定义)的患病率为6.9%(95%置信区间(CI)5.1 - 9.2),12至66个月大儿童中77.8%的改良视黄醇剂量反应(MRDR)试验结果异常(95%CI 68.27 - 85.17)。1999年,这种情况有了显著改善,干眼症患病率降至3.3%(95%CI 2.1 - 5.2),MRDR试验异常反应率降至63.1%(95%CI 54.25 - 71.23)。1997年至1999年期间感染发病率呈下降趋势。在年龄大于国家免疫日目标年龄的儿童中未发现显著改善。1999年,接受维生素A的儿童患干眼症的风险较低(接受者为3.0%,未接受者为8.7%),且感染事件较少。
1997年至1999年期间,学龄前儿童的临床和生物学维生素A状况有所改善。维生素A的大规模分发似乎减少了干眼症的发生,并且似乎与其他相关疾病的减少有关。当维生素A缺乏仍然是一个公共卫生问题时,国家免疫日期间的维生素A补充应被高度重视。