Babić-Banaszak Andreja, Kovacić Luka, Mastilica Miroslav
Medicinski fakultet Sveucilista u Zagrebu Skola narodnog zdravlja Andrija Stampar Rockefellerova 4 10000 Zagreb.
Acta Med Croatica. 2002;56(4-5):145-50.
Since self-perceived health represents an important indicator of health status, the aim of this study was to explore socioeconomic differences in self-perceived health in Croatia.
The study was conducted during the 1997-1999 period in fourteen Croatian counties. A sample of 5,048 respondents aged 18 years and older were recruited by multistaged stratified sampling. Data were collected using an anonymous questionnaire which consisted of questions on the respondents' socioeconomic characteristics and self-perceived health.
While 20.7% of the respondents evaluated their health as poor, 25.9% evaluated it as excellent or very good. Women, older respondents and those with lower educational level and lower income more frequently described their health as poor. When comparing their health to the health of age-matched persons, 23.6% of the respondents thought their health was better and 21.0% thought their health was worse than the health of persons of the same age. Women, older respondents and those with lower educational level and lower income more frequently thought their health was worse than the health of their coevals. As many as 53.7% of the respondents thought their health had not changed compared to the previous year, and 31.7% thought their health was worse than in the previous year. Older respondents, respondents with lower income and those with lower educational level more frequently thought that their health had worsened compared to the previous year.
Results of the study revealed a complex relationship between socioeconomic factors and self-perceived health. Men and women differed significantly in self-perceived health. Women mostly described their health as being poor or satisfactory, while men described it as excellent or very good. These results, similar to those in a large body of literature, raise the question of gender differences in the perception of symptoms. In our research, self-perceived health was poorer in older respondents. This also applies to the comparison of self-perceived health to the health of age-matched persons. An exception was the group of respondents aged > 76; their self-perceived health was described as either much worse or much better than the health of their coevals. Older persons are inevitably sicker than younger ones and poor self-perceived health would be expected. Nevertheless, the relation between self-perceived health and age is sometimes ambiguous in the literature. Income and education are strong markers of socioeconomic status. In our research, respondents with lower income as well as those with lower educational level had poorer self-perceived health. Education is a particularly strong marker of socioeconomic status, and it predicts self-perceived health better than occupation does. A study of self-perceived health does not always give an accurate insight into the real self-perceived health of the respondents. For example, if a person, otherwise in good health, suffered from an acute condition, he could describe his health as being poor at that moment. We tried to minimize this potential bias by adding two questions in self-perceived health assessment--"How do you perceive your health compared to your health a year ago?" and "How do you perceive your health compared to health of the persons of the same age?" Women, older respondents, respondents with lower educational level and lower income generally described their health as poor more often. Since self-perceived health is correlated with health care utilization, these results could be used to identify the specific population groups who are more likely to be potential users of health care services.
Since education and income represent socioeconomic parameters, it could be concluded that self-perceived health of the respondents with lower socioeconomic status is poorer than self-perceived health of those with higher socioeconomic status.
由于自我认知健康是健康状况的一项重要指标,本研究旨在探究克罗地亚自我认知健康方面的社会经济差异。
该研究于1997 - 1999年期间在克罗地亚的14个县开展。通过多阶段分层抽样招募了5048名年龄在18岁及以上的受访者。使用一份匿名问卷收集数据,问卷包含有关受访者社会经济特征和自我认知健康的问题。
20.7%的受访者将自己的健康状况评价为差,25.9%的受访者将其评价为优秀或非常好。女性、年龄较大的受访者以及教育水平和收入较低的受访者更常将自己的健康状况描述为差。当将自己的健康与年龄相仿者的健康进行比较时,23.6%的受访者认为自己的健康状况更好,21.0%的受访者认为自己的健康状况比同龄人差。女性、年龄较大的受访者以及教育水平和收入较低的受访者更常认为自己的健康状况比同龄人差。多达53.7%的受访者认为自己的健康状况与上一年相比没有变化,31.7%的受访者认为自己的健康状况比上一年差。年龄较大的受访者、收入较低的受访者以及教育水平较低的受访者更常认为自己的健康状况与上一年相比变差了。
研究结果揭示了社会经济因素与自我认知健康之间的复杂关系。男性和女性在自我认知健康方面存在显著差异。女性大多将自己的健康状况描述为差或一般,而男性则将其描述为优秀或非常好。这些结果与大量文献中的结果相似,引发了关于症状感知中性别差异的问题。在我们的研究中,年龄较大的受访者自我认知健康状况较差。这也适用于将自我认知健康与年龄相仿者的健康进行比较的情况。一个例外是年龄大于76岁的受访者群体;他们的自我认知健康状况被描述为比同龄人差很多或好很多。老年人不可避免地比年轻人更容易生病,自我认知健康状况较差是可以预期的。然而,自我认知健康与年龄之间的关系在文献中有时并不明确。收入和教育是社会经济地位的重要标志。在我们的研究中,收入较低以及教育水平较低的受访者自我认知健康状况较差。教育是社会经济地位的一个特别强的标志,它比职业更能预测自我认知健康状况。对自我认知健康的研究并不总是能准确洞察受访者的实际自我认知健康状况。例如,如果一个人原本健康状况良好,但患有急性疾病,他可能在那时将自己的健康状况描述为差。我们试图通过在自我认知健康评估中增加两个问题来尽量减少这种潜在偏差——“与一年前相比,你如何看待自己的健康状况?”以及“与同龄人相比,你如何看待自己的健康状况?”女性、年龄较大的受访者、教育水平较低的受访者以及收入较低的受访者通常更常将自己的健康状况描述为差。由于自我认知健康与医疗保健利用相关,这些结果可用于识别更有可能成为医疗保健服务潜在使用者的特定人群。
由于教育和收入代表社会经济参数,可以得出结论,社会经济地位较低的受访者的自我认知健康状况比社会经济地位较高的受访者差。