De Smet L, Londers J
Department of Orthopedic Surgery, U.Z. Pellenberg, Weligerveld 1, B-3212 Lubbeek, Pellenberg, Belgium.
Acta Orthop Belg. 2003 Apr;69(2):142-4.
This study was set up to test our hypothesis that using the Jamar dynamometer a voluntary submaximal effort has a greater variability compared to a real maximal effort, especially when there is a long interval between different measurements. We tested 32 volunteers without a history of upper limb injury or operation in our hospital, with an interval of four to five weeks between tests. Each volunteer was asked to grip first right-handed then left-handed, first with a real maximal effort and then with a submaximal effort. This test was performed twice during the same session. The same individuals were seen again one month later and were studied using the same protocol. Sensitivities and specificities for the grip test were calculated using six different criteria to indicate a submaximal effort. Repeated grip testing with a time interval of one month cannot reliably detect voluntary submaximal effort in healthy volunteers.
本研究旨在检验我们的假设,即使用贾马尔握力计进行自愿性次最大努力时,与真正的最大努力相比,其变异性更大,尤其是在不同测量之间存在较长间隔时。我们测试了32名在我院无上肢损伤或手术史的志愿者,两次测试间隔四到五周。要求每位志愿者先右手后左手进行握力测试,先进行真正的最大努力,然后进行次最大努力。该测试在同一时段内进行两次。一个月后再次观察相同个体,并使用相同方案进行研究。使用六种不同标准计算握力测试的敏感性和特异性,以表明次最大努力。在健康志愿者中,间隔一个月进行重复握力测试无法可靠地检测到自愿性次最大努力。