Carroll E M, Brennan P C
UCD School of Diagnostic Imaging, St. Anthony's, Herbert Avenue, Dublin 4, Ireland.
Eur Radiol. 2003 Jul;13(7):1529-33. doi: 10.1007/s00330-002-1792-5. Epub 2003 Jan 22.
With the introduction of Council Directive 97/43/Euratom, all member states should establish relevant diagnostic reference levels for X-ray examinations. Diagnostic reference levels help to facilitate standardisation and optimisation within departments and attempt to reduce dose variations between hospitals. High variation of individual patient doses for plain-film examinations by up to a factor of 75 was demonstrated by a previous Irish study, which highlighted the necessity for further investigation into other examinations in Ireland. The current work aimed to establish reference values for intravenous urography (IVU) examinations, an important contributor to collective dose. Eleven Irish hospitals were randomly selected, representing 30% of the total number of hospitals. Dose-area product (DAP) readings for IVUs were recorded along with technical and procedural details. Resultant data demonstrated mean hospital and individual patient DAP variations of a factor of 4 and 58, respectively. Stepwise regression analysis demonstrated that number of images taken, method of image acquisition and patient weight were the main causal agents for dose variations recorded. A proposed diagnostic reference level of 12 Gy cm(2) was established at the level of the third-quartile value of the mean hospital DAP values. This article provides evidence of large variations in DAP values for IVU examinations. It is hoped that application of the proposed DRL of 12 Gy cm(2 )will reduce the size of these variations.
随着《欧洲原子能共同体理事会指令97/43/Euratom》的出台,所有成员国都应针对X射线检查制定相关的诊断参考水平。诊断参考水平有助于促进各部门的标准化和优化,并试图减少医院之间的剂量差异。爱尔兰此前的一项研究表明,普通X线检查中个体患者剂量的差异高达75倍,这凸显了对爱尔兰其他检查进行进一步调查的必要性。当前的工作旨在为静脉肾盂造影(IVU)检查确定参考值,IVU检查是集体剂量的一个重要贡献因素。随机选取了11家爱尔兰医院,占医院总数的30%。记录了IVU检查的剂量面积乘积(DAP)读数以及技术和程序细节。所得数据表明,医院和个体患者的平均DAP差异分别为4倍和58倍。逐步回归分析表明,拍摄的图像数量、图像采集方法和患者体重是记录的剂量差异的主要原因。在医院平均DAP值的第三四分位数水平上确定了12 Gy cm²的建议诊断参考水平。本文提供了IVU检查中DAP值存在较大差异的证据。希望应用12 Gy cm²的建议诊断参考水平能够减小这些差异的幅度。