Schulman Elliott A, Dermott Kathleen F
Center for Headache Management, Ambulatory Care Pavilion, Suite 533, One Medical Center Boulevard, Upland, PA 19013, USA.
Headache. 2003 Jul-Aug;43(7):729-33. doi: 10.1046/j.1526-4610.2003.03130.x.
We evaluated the effectiveness of combination treatment using sumatriptan plus metoclopramide versus sumatriptan alone for the treatment of acute migraine. The patients who were treated had failed to respond to triptans in the past despite adequate doses on at least 2 separate trials of the same triptan or 2 trials involving different triptans.
There is limited evidence that dopaminergic antagonists may benefit the migraineur by relieving migraine pain and associated symptoms. The exact mechanism of action in migraine is unknown. The postulated action is the inhibition of dopaminergic overactivity. A dopaminergic antagonist, metoclopramide, may improve the efficacy of a 5-HT1B/1D agonist, sumatriptan.
In this double-blind, randomized, crossover study, 16 adult migraineurs fulfilling International Headache Society (IHS) criteria for migraine with or without aura who had failed to receive adequate relief from triptans treated one migraine with each treatment: sumatriptan 50 mg plus metoclopramide 10 mg or sumatriptan 50 mg plus placebo to match metoclopramide. Patients treated their migraines when they were moderate or severe in intensity and recorded pain severity and symptoms prior to treatment and 30, 60, 90, and 120 minutes and 24 hours after treatment.
Thirteen women and 3 men (mean age, 40 years) completed the study; ie, treated 2 migraines (a total of 32 migraines), one attack with each treatment. Meaningful relief was attained in 10 (63%) of 16 migraines treated with the combination of sumatriptan 50 mg plus metoclopramide 10 mg compared with 5 (31%) of 16 migraines treated with sumatriptan 50 mg plus placebo. Headache response (moderate or severe to mild or no pain at 2 hours) was achieved in 7 (44%) of 16 migraines with the combination of sumatriptan 50 mg plus metoclopramide 10 mg compared with 5 (31%) of 16 migraines treated with sumatriptan 50 mg plus placebo. There did not appear to be a difference between treatment groups with respect to associated symptoms. The combination of sumatriptan 50 mg plus metoclopramide 10 mg was well tolerated.
Combining sumatriptan with metoclopramide provided relief in some migraineurs who failed to achieve adequate relief with a triptan alone. It remains unknown whether initiating therapy when pain was mild or using a higher dose of sumatriptan (ie, 100 mg) would have provided additional benefit. Further studies are indicated.
我们评估了舒马曲坦联合甲氧氯普胺与单用舒马曲坦治疗急性偏头痛的有效性。过去接受治疗的患者,尽管在至少2次单独的相同曲坦类药物试验或2次涉及不同曲坦类药物的试验中使用了足够剂量,但对曲坦类药物仍无反应。
仅有有限的证据表明多巴胺能拮抗剂可能通过缓解偏头痛疼痛及相关症状而使偏头痛患者获益。其在偏头痛中的确切作用机制尚不清楚。推测的作用是抑制多巴胺能活性亢进。一种多巴胺能拮抗剂,甲氧氯普胺,可能会提高5-HT1B/1D激动剂舒马曲坦的疗效。
在这项双盲、随机、交叉研究中,16名符合国际头痛协会(IHS)有或无先兆偏头痛标准且未从曲坦类药物中获得充分缓解的成年偏头痛患者,每种治疗方法各治疗一次偏头痛:舒马曲坦50毫克加甲氧氯普胺10毫克或舒马曲坦50毫克加安慰剂以匹配甲氧氯普胺。患者在偏头痛为中度或重度时进行治疗,并记录治疗前以及治疗后30、60、90和120分钟及24小时的疼痛严重程度和症状。
13名女性和3名男性(平均年龄40岁)完成了研究;即治疗了2次偏头痛(共32次偏头痛),每种治疗方法各治疗一次发作。16次用舒马曲坦50毫克加甲氧氯普胺10毫克联合治疗的偏头痛中有10次(63%)获得了显著缓解,而16次用舒马曲坦50毫克加安慰剂治疗的偏头痛中有5次(31%)获得缓解。16次用舒马曲坦50毫克加甲氧氯普胺10毫克联合治疗的偏头痛中有7次(44%)在2小时时头痛反应(从中度或重度变为轻度或无痛),而16次用舒马曲坦50毫克加安慰剂治疗的偏头痛中有5次(31%)有此反应。治疗组在相关症状方面似乎没有差异。舒马曲坦50毫克加甲氧氯普胺10毫克联合治疗耐受性良好。
对于单用曲坦类药物未能获得充分缓解的一些偏头痛患者,舒马曲坦与甲氧氯普胺联合使用可提供缓解。疼痛轻微时开始治疗或使用更高剂量的舒马曲坦(即100毫克)是否会带来额外益处仍不清楚。需要进一步研究。