Blass R B
Department of psychology, Hebrew University of Jerusalem.
Psychoanal Study Child. 1992;47:159-87. doi: 10.1080/00797308.1992.11822670.
A careful review of the Dora case refutes the commonly held view that it reflects Freud's adoption of his classical oedipal model. Through Dora, Freud examined some of the theoretical and emotional underpinnings of the seduction theory and began a complex and very gradual move toward an oedipal model, never reaching his classical formulation. The transitional nature of this case allows for an understanding of some of Freud's difficulties in adopting the oedipal model and the considerations that, nevertheless, eventually determined the move. How and why this was overlooked in all later studies of the case has important implications for the process of development of psychoanalytic theory and the writing of its history.
对朵拉案例的仔细审视驳斥了一种普遍观点,即该案例反映了弗洛伊德对其经典俄狄浦斯模型的采用。通过朵拉案例,弗洛伊德审视了诱惑理论的一些理论和情感基础,并开始了一个复杂且非常渐进的向俄狄浦斯模型的转变,但从未达到他的经典表述。该案例的过渡性质有助于理解弗洛伊德在采用俄狄浦斯模型时所遇到的一些困难,以及那些最终决定了这一转变的考量因素。在该案例后来的所有研究中,这一点是如何以及为何被忽视的,对于精神分析理论的发展过程及其历史撰写具有重要意义。