Lucchini Roberto, Calza Stefano, Camerino Donatella, Carta Plinio, Decarli Adriano, Parrinello Giovanni, Soleo Leonardo, Zefferino Roberto, Alessio Lorenzo
Institute of Occupational Health and Industrial Hygiene, University of Brescia, Brescia, Italy.
Neurotoxicology. 2003 Aug;24(4-5):605-16. doi: 10.1016/S0161-813X(03)00048-2.
A latent variable model was applied to the results of an Italian multicenter nation-wide cross-sectional study to assess the earliest health effects due to mercury (Hg) exposure caused by occupation, dental amalgams (DENTAM) and fish eating (FISH). The studied population included subjects recruited from four different geographical areas. A total number of 122 workers from chloroalkali plants and production of thermometers and neon lamps formed the occupationally exposed group, whereas 196 subjects, recruited from the same areas and not occupationally exposed to mercury, formed the control group. Neuropsychological functions were assessed with neurobehavioral testing including vigilance, motor and cognitive function, tremor measurements, and with symptoms concerning neuropsychological and mood assessment. Neuroendocrine function was examined with the measurement of prolactin (PRL) level. Parameters of immunological and renal function were also measured. The target population was characterized by the number and surface of dental amalgams and consumption of fish. In the exposed workers the average urinary mercury (U-Hg) was 10.4+/-6.9 (geometric mean 8.3, range 0.2-35.2) microg/g creatinine, whereas in the control group it was 1.9+/-2.8 (geometric mean 1.2, range 0.1-33.2) microg/g creatinine. The preliminary results indicated that finger tapping (FT) and the Branches alternate movement task (BAMT) coordination test were associated with the occupational exposure (OCCEXP). PRL was significantly decreased among the exposed workers, and inversely related to U-Hg. Among the immunological and renal parameters, cytokine serum interleuchin-8 (sIL8) and beta(2) micro globulin (beta(2)MG) were lower in the exposed group and negatively correlated to U-Hg. Small-size fish consumption was associated to a beneficial effect on symptoms reporting. No effects were observed concerning dental amalgams. After first evaluating the relationship between mercury exposure and each indicator of effect, further assessment was performed to identify the earliest effects related to mercury exposure among those who resulted in being associated in the preliminary elaboration. Two latent variables "exposure" and "effect" were identified, integrating respectively the different forms of exposure (occupational, due to dental amalgams and fish consumption) and the indicators of effects (FT, BAMT, PRL, sIL8, beta(2)MG). Confounding factors (age, alcohol, body mass index (BMI)) were considered in the same model. This further analysis showed that an inverse association of occupational exposure to mercury with PRL and BAMT, with Hg-U mediating the effect on PRL, was predominant with respect to the other form of mercury exposure, the other indicators of effect and the confounders. In conclusion, this study supports the finding of alterations of neuroendocrine secretion and motor coordination at very low occupational exposure levels of inorganic mercury, below the current ACGIH Biological Exposure Index. These changes occur at lower levels than other subtle effects on the renal function and the immunitary system. On the contrary, dental amalgams and small-size fish consumption do not seem to be associated to any adverse health effect at these exposure levels.
将一个潜在变量模型应用于一项意大利多中心全国性横断面研究的结果,以评估因职业、牙科汞合金(DENTAM)和食用鱼类导致的汞(Hg)暴露所产生的最早健康影响。研究人群包括从四个不同地理区域招募的受试者。来自氯碱厂以及温度计和霓虹灯生产厂的122名工人构成职业暴露组,而从相同区域招募的196名未职业性接触汞的受试者构成对照组。通过包括警觉性、运动和认知功能、震颤测量的神经行为测试以及关于神经心理学和情绪评估的症状来评估神经心理学功能。通过测量催乳素(PRL)水平来检查神经内分泌功能。还测量了免疫和肾功能参数。目标人群以牙科汞合金的数量和表面积以及鱼类消费量为特征。在暴露工人中,尿汞(U-Hg)平均为10.4±6.9(几何均值8.3,范围0.2 - 35.2)μg/g肌酐,而对照组为1.9±2.8(几何均值1.2,范围0.1 - 33.2)μg/g肌酐。初步结果表明,手指敲击(FT)和分支交替运动任务(BAMT)协调测试与职业暴露(OCCEXP)相关。暴露工人中的PRL显著降低,且与U-Hg呈负相关。在免疫和肾参数中,暴露组的细胞因子血清白细胞介素-8(sIL8)和β2微球蛋白(β2MG)较低,且与U-Hg呈负相关。食用小型鱼类与对症状报告的有益影响相关。未观察到牙科汞合金有任何影响。在首先评估汞暴露与每种效应指标之间的关系后,进行了进一步评估,以确定在初步分析中显示相关的那些人中与汞暴露相关的最早效应。识别出两个潜在变量“暴露”和“效应”,分别整合了不同形式的暴露(职业性、因牙科汞合金和食用鱼类)和效应指标(FT、BAMT、PRL、sIL8、β2MG)。在同一模型中考虑了混杂因素(年龄、酒精、体重指数(BMI))。这一进一步分析表明,相对于其他形式的汞暴露、其他效应指标和混杂因素,职业性汞暴露与PRL和BAMT呈负相关,Hg-U介导了对PRL的影响,这一关联最为显著。总之,本研究支持以下发现:在低于当前美国政府工业卫生学家会议(ACGIH)生物暴露指数的极低职业性无机汞暴露水平下,神经内分泌分泌和运动协调会发生改变。这些变化发生的水平低于对肾功能和免疫系统的其他细微影响。相反,在这些暴露水平下,牙科汞合金和食用小型鱼类似乎与任何不良健康影响均无关联。