Cree Marilyn W, Juby Angela G, Carriere Keumhee C
Department of Mathematical and Statistical Sciences, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada.
Osteoporos Int. 2003 Sep;14(9):722-7. doi: 10.1007/s00198-003-1430-3. Epub 2003 Aug 7.
This study examined post-fracture osteoporosis drug treatment in hip fracture patients and the association of treatment with mortality and morbidity. Pre- and post-fracture demographic/health information was collected on a cohort of hip fracture patients aged 65+ years. Post-fracture administrative data on prescription drug use and health care utilization was linked to the cohort data. Five classes of osteoporosis drugs were available during the study period: hormone replacement therapy (HRT), bisphosphonates (BSP), calcitonin, selective estrogen receptor modulators (SERMs) and vitamin D(3) (Rocaltrol). Pre-fracture, 38 of 449 patients (8%) were on osteoporosis medications. Post-fracture, 81 of 356 patients (23%) were treated; 63 of these patients were untreated prior to fracture. Both treated and untreated patients had similar rates of subsequent hip fracture (6% and 4%, respectively) and Colles fracture (2%). Regardless of treatment status, patients were also equally likely to be hospitalized, both in the short-term (28% in treated, 27% in untreated) and in the long-term (43% versus 37%). However, mortality was significantly lower in the treated group. The lower mortality in the treated group, combined with the knowledge that antiresorptive drugs reduce fractures and increase bone density, merit undertaking a randomized trial to confirm our findings that antiresorptive therapy should be considered in all patients post-hip fracture.
本研究调查了髋部骨折患者骨折后的骨质疏松药物治疗情况以及治疗与死亡率和发病率之间的关联。收集了一组65岁及以上髋部骨折患者骨折前后的人口统计学/健康信息。将骨折后有关处方药使用和医疗保健利用的行政数据与队列数据相关联。在研究期间有五类骨质疏松药物:激素替代疗法(HRT)、双膦酸盐(BSP)、降钙素、选择性雌激素受体调节剂(SERM)和维生素D(3)(罗钙全)。骨折前,449名患者中有38名(8%)正在使用骨质疏松药物。骨折后,356名患者中有81名(23%)接受了治疗;其中63名患者在骨折前未接受治疗。接受治疗和未接受治疗的患者随后发生髋部骨折的比例相似(分别为6%和4%),发生Colles骨折的比例也相似(2%)。无论治疗状态如何,患者短期(治疗组为28%,未治疗组为27%)和长期(分别为43%和37%)住院的可能性也相同。然而,治疗组的死亡率显著较低。治疗组较低的死亡率,再加上抗吸收药物可减少骨折并增加骨密度这一认识,值得进行一项随机试验,以证实我们的发现,即所有髋部骨折后的患者都应考虑接受抗吸收治疗。