Kim J E, Kim D G, Paek S H, Jung H-W
Department of Neurosurgery, Seoul National University College of Medicine, Clinical Research Institute, Seoul National University Hospital, Seoul, Korea.
Acta Neurochir (Wien). 2003 Jul;145(7):547-54; discussion 554-5. doi: 10.1007/s00701-003-0048-8.
The authors present a retrospective analysis of 308 computed tomography (CT)-guided stereotactic biopsies in 300 patients in order to evaluate the reliability and efficacy of the stereotactic biopsy for intracranial lesions.
All patients were suffering from undetermined intracranial lesions and treated at Seoul National University Hospital between January 1993 and December 1999. Age ranged from three to 79 years (mean 41); the male to female ratio was 180:120. All patients underwent CT-guided stereotactic biopsy for the histological verification and/or evacuation of the cyst using Riechert-Mundinger stereotactic system.
Histological diagnosis was made in 275 patients (diagnostic yield 91.7%). Diagnostic yield was better in group with frozen section examination during the stereotactic procedure than the group without it (p=0.01). Neoplastic lesions were more likely to be diagnosed in stereotactic biopsy than non-neoplastic lesions (p=0.02). Among 30 patients who underwent craniotomy after the stereotactic biopsy, the histological diagnoses after the craniotomy were identical to those of the stereotactic biopsy in 29 patients (diagnostic accuracy 96.7%). Two patients died within seven days after the stereotactic biopsy (mortality 0.6%). The postoperative new neurological deficit or aggravation of the neurological status was found in 19 patients, including transient cases of seven patients (permanent morbidity rate 3.9%). Histologically malignant gliomas and deeply-located lesions were the significant risk factors for the development of complications. In 148 cases, histological diagnosis of the stereotactic biopsy was different from the preoperative clinical diagnosis. Among these cases, the treatment plan was changed after stereotactic biopsy in 81 cases.
Stereotactic biopsy for intracranial lesions is a reliable and relatively safe procedure. It is also a very efficacious method especially in patients who need histological confirmation for the treatment.
作者对300例患者的308次计算机断层扫描(CT)引导下立体定向活检进行回顾性分析,以评估立体定向活检对颅内病变的可靠性和有效性。
所有患者均患有未明确的颅内病变,并于1993年1月至1999年12月在首尔国立大学医院接受治疗。年龄范围为3至79岁(平均41岁);男女比例为180:120。所有患者均使用Riechert-Mundinger立体定向系统接受CT引导下立体定向活检,以进行组织学验证和/或囊肿引流。
275例患者获得组织学诊断(诊断率91.7%)。立体定向手术过程中进行冰冻切片检查的组诊断率高于未进行冰冻切片检查的组(p=0.01)。立体定向活检中肿瘤性病变比非肿瘤性病变更易被诊断(p=0.02)。在30例立体定向活检后接受开颅手术的患者中,29例开颅手术后的组织学诊断与立体定向活检的诊断相同(诊断准确率96.7%)。2例患者在立体定向活检后7天内死亡(死亡率0.6%)。19例患者出现术后新的神经功能缺损或神经状态恶化,其中包括7例短暂性病例(永久性发病率3.9%)。组织学上的恶性胶质瘤和深部病变是并发症发生的重要危险因素。在148例病例中,立体定向活检的组织学诊断与术前临床诊断不同。在这些病例中,81例在立体定向活检后改变了治疗方案。
颅内病变的立体定向活检是一种可靠且相对安全的手术。它也是一种非常有效的方法,尤其适用于需要组织学确诊以进行治疗的患者。