Chomitz Virginia R, Collins Jessica, Kim Juhee, Kramer Ellen, McGowan Robert
Institute for Community Health, Cambridge Public Schools, Cambridge, MA 02139, USA.
Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med. 2003 Aug;157(8):765-72. doi: 10.1001/archpedi.157.8.765.
As overweight continues to rise among children, schools seek effective and sensitive ways to engage parents in promoting healthy weight.
To evaluate a school-based health report card on the family awareness of and concern about the child weight status, plans for weight control, and preventive behaviors.
Quasi-experimental field trial with a personalized weight and fitness health report card intervention (PI), a general-information intervention (GI), and a control group (CG). Outcomes were assessed using a postintervention telephone survey, including process and outcome measures.
The intervention included 1396 ethnically diverse students at 4 elementary schools in an urban area. Telephone surveys were completed by 399 families from an evaluation sample of 793. Intervention Families were randomly assigned to the PI, GI, or CG and mailed intervention materials. The CG was mailed GI materials after the survey.
Parent awareness of child weight status, concerns, weight-control plans, and preventive behaviors. Group effects were significantly different by the child's weight status, so results were stratified.
Among overweight students, intervention parents were more likely to know their child's weight status (PI, 44%; GI, 41%; CG, 23%) (P =.02). The PI parents planned medical help (PI, 25%; GI, 7%; CG, 9%) (P =.004), dieting activities (PI, 19%; GI and CG, <5 cases) (P =.02) and physical activities (PI, 42%; GI, 27%; CG, 13%) (P<.001) for their overweight children. No group effect on concern or preventive behaviors was detected. Most parents of overweight children who read materials requested annual weight and health information on their child (PI, 91%; GI, 67%).
Among overweight children, the PI was associated with increased parental awareness of their child's weight status. Although parents wanted PI for their children, more research is needed to test this approach on children's self-esteem and plans for weight control.
随着儿童超重现象持续增加,学校寻求有效且灵敏的方式让家长参与到促进健康体重的行动中。
评估一份基于学校的健康报告卡,内容涉及家长对孩子体重状况的知晓度与关注度、体重控制计划以及预防行为。
采用准实验性现场试验,设有个性化体重与健身健康报告卡干预组(PI)、一般信息干预组(GI)和对照组(CG)。通过干预后电话调查评估结果,包括过程和结果指标。
干预涉及市区4所小学的1396名不同种族的学生。电话调查由来自793个评估样本中的399个家庭完成。干预家庭被随机分配到PI组、GI组或CG组,并邮寄干预材料。对照组在调查后邮寄GI组材料。
家长对孩子体重状况的知晓度、关注度、体重控制计划以及预防行为。因孩子的体重状况不同,组间效应存在显著差异,所以结果进行了分层分析。
在超重学生中,干预组家长更有可能知晓孩子的体重状况(PI组为44%;GI组为41%;CG组为23%)(P = 0.02)。PI组家长为超重孩子计划寻求医疗帮助(PI组为25%;GI组为7%;CG组为9%)(P = 0.004)、节食活动(PI组为19%;GI组和CG组均少于5例)(P = 0.02)以及体育活动(PI组为42%;GI组为27%;CG组为13%)(P<0.001)。未检测到对关注度或预防行为的组间效应。阅读材料的超重孩子的大多数家长要求获取孩子的年度体重和健康信息(PI组为91%;GI组为67%)。
在超重儿童中,PI组与家长对孩子体重状况的知晓度增加有关。尽管家长希望为孩子采用PI组方式,但仍需要更多研究来检验这种方法对儿童自尊和体重控制计划的影响。