Young T Kue
Department of Public Health Sciences, Faculty of Medicine, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario, Canada M5S 1A8.
BMJ. 2003 Aug 23;327(7412):419-22. doi: 10.1136/bmj.327.7412.419.
To determine if research has adequately examined the health needs of the aboriginal population of Canada.
Review.
Medline search of journal articles published during 1992-2001. The search terms used were "Canada" and various synonyms and categories for Canadian aboriginal people. Each paper was categorised according to the aboriginal group, age-sex group, comparison group, geographic location, and type of research topic (health determinant, health status, or health care).
Of 352 citations found, 254 were selected after elimination of those without abstracts, not containing data on Canada, or not focusing on health issues. The proportion of papers does not reflect the demographic composition of aboriginal people in Canada, with severe under-representation of Métis, urban aboriginal people, and First Nations people not living on reserves and over-representation of the Inuit. Children and women received less attention proportional to their share of the population. A few prolific research groups have generated a disproportionate amount of publications from a few communities and regions. 174 papers dealt with health determinants (for example, genetics, diet, and contaminants), 173 with health status, and 75 with health care. Injuries, which account for a third of all deaths, were studied in only 8 papers. None of the health care papers examined rehabilitation.
Researchers have not adequately examined several important health needs of the aboriginal population.
确定研究是否充分考察了加拿大原住民的健康需求。
综述。
对1992 - 2001年期间发表的期刊文章进行Medline检索。使用的检索词为“加拿大”以及加拿大原住民的各种同义词和类别。每篇论文根据原住民群体、年龄 - 性别组、对照组、地理位置以及研究主题类型(健康决定因素、健康状况或医疗保健)进行分类。
在检索到的352条引用中,剔除没有摘要、不包含加拿大数据或未关注健康问题的文献后,选取了254篇。论文比例并不反映加拿大原住民的人口构成,梅蒂斯人、城市原住民以及不住在保留地的第一民族人严重缺乏代表性,而因纽特人则代表性过高。儿童和妇女按其在人口中的比例获得的关注较少。少数多产的研究团队从少数社区和地区产出了不成比例数量的出版物。174篇论文涉及健康决定因素(如遗传学、饮食和污染物),173篇涉及健康状况,75篇涉及医疗保健。占所有死亡人数三分之一的伤害问题仅在8篇论文中得到研究。没有一篇医疗保健论文考察康复情况。
研究人员尚未充分考察原住民的若干重要健康需求。