Fung Man C, Takayama Shimako, Ishiguro Hiroshi, Sakata Tohru, Adachi Susumu, Morizane Toshio
Oncology Dept. Japan Clinical Research, Eli Lilly and Company, Japan KK.
Gan To Kagaku Ryoho. 2003 Aug;30(8):1101-11.
Pancreatic cancer represents a major challenge to oncologists because of its high chemoresistant nature and dismal outcomes, especially in advanced diseases. Clinical trials on the effects of systemic chemotherapy for patients with advanced pancreatic cancer have not been shown to have consistent benefits. A systematic review and meta-analysis was therefore conducted to examine this issue. All randomized trials on chemotherapy treatment for advanced pancreatic cancer published since the 1970's were identified by means of Medline and other major oncology databases. Systematic review of all trials was carefully conducted and data from trials with similar designs and regimens were pooled and grouped together in the benefit outcome analyses. Data for 5,365 patients from 43 randomized controlled trials were identified. Survival benefit over best supportive care was demonstrated in 5-FU-based chemotherapy in 9 randomized trials. However, trials that comparing 5-FU or other cytotoxic agent alone versus 5-FU-based combinations did not show any statistical differences, nor were various 5-FU-combinations comparing among themselves. On the other hand, gemcitabine was shown to improve survival and clinical benefit responses better than 5-FU and other new agents. Overall, these results were encouraging and future research to explore means to optimize drug treatment (especially gemcitabine-based regimens) for advanced pancreatic cancer is warranted.
胰腺癌因其高度的化学抗性和令人沮丧的治疗结果,尤其是在晚期疾病中,对肿瘤学家来说是一项重大挑战。针对晚期胰腺癌患者进行的全身化疗效果的临床试验尚未显示出一致的益处。因此,进行了一项系统评价和荟萃分析来研究这个问题。通过医学文献数据库(Medline)和其他主要肿瘤学数据库,检索了自20世纪70年代以来发表的所有关于晚期胰腺癌化疗治疗的随机试验。对所有试验进行了仔细的系统评价,并将设计和方案相似的试验数据汇总在一起进行疗效分析。确定了来自43项随机对照试验的5365名患者的数据。在9项随机试验中,基于5-氟尿嘧啶(5-FU)的化疗显示出生存获益优于最佳支持治疗。然而,比较单独使用5-FU或其他细胞毒性药物与基于5-FU的联合用药的试验未显示出任何统计学差异,不同的5-FU联合用药之间也未显示出差异。另一方面,吉西他滨显示出比5-FU和其他新药更好的生存改善和临床获益反应。总体而言这些结果令人鼓舞值得开展进一步研究以探索优化晚期胰腺癌药物治疗(尤其是基于吉西他滨的方案)的方法。