Milling Leonard S, Levine Michelle R, Meunier Suzanne A
Department of Psychology, University of Hartford, Connecticut 06110, USA.
Health Psychol. 2003 Jul;22(4):406-13. doi: 10.1037/0278-6133.22.4.406.
Recent meta-analyses have shown that adding hypnosis enhances the effectiveness of cognitive-behavioral psychotherapy. This hypnotic enhancement effect was evaluated in the analogue treatment of pain. Individuals scoring in the high (n = 135) and low (n = 150) ranges of hypnotic suggestibility were randomly assigned to 1 of 6 conditions: Stress Inoculation Training, the same treatment provided hypnotically, nonhypnotic analgesia suggestions, hypnotic analgesia suggestions, a hypnotic induction treatment, or a control condition. The 5 analogue treatments reduced experimental pain more than the control condition, but were not different from one another. Under circumstances optimized to detect an enhancement effect, neither Stress Inoculation Training nor analgesia suggestions produced more relief when delivered in a hypnotic context than identical treatments provided nonhypnotically.
近期的荟萃分析表明,增加催眠可提高认知行为心理治疗的效果。这种催眠增强效应在疼痛的模拟治疗中得到了评估。将高催眠易感性(n = 135)和低催眠易感性(n = 150)范围内得分的个体随机分配到6种条件中的1种:压力接种训练、同样的治疗但采用催眠方式、非催眠性镇痛建议、催眠性镇痛建议、催眠诱导治疗或对照条件。这5种模拟治疗比对照条件更能减轻实验性疼痛,但彼此之间没有差异。在优化以检测增强效应的情况下,无论是压力接种训练还是镇痛建议,在催眠情境下实施时,与非催眠方式提供的相同治疗相比,都没有产生更多的缓解效果。