Vajda Frank J, O'Brien Terence J, Hitchcock Alison, Graham Janet, Lander Cecilie
Australian Centre For Neuropharmacology, Raoul Wallenberg Centre, St. Vincent's Hospital, Melbourne, Australia.
J Clin Neurosci. 2003 Sep;10(5):543-9. doi: 10.1016/s0967-5868(03)00158-9.
Most women with epilepsy need to take antiepileptic drugs (AEDs) in pregnancy to prevent the potentially harmful effects of seizures. Retrospective studies have demonstrated an increased chance of having a child with a birth defect (BD) in women with epilepsy taking AEDs. It is uncertain how much of this risk is directly caused by the AEDs and whether certain drugs or combinations are associated with a greater risk.
To establish a register to evaluate prospectively the incidence of adverse pregnancy outcomes in women exposed to specific AEDs; to determine whether certain AEDs or combinations were associated with a greater risk; and to determine whether other factors influenced the risk.
An Australia-wide, prospective, voluntary, telephone-interview based, observational register. Three groups of pregnant women were enrolled: those with epilepsy taking AEDs, those with epilepsy not taking AEDs, and those taking AEDs for a non-epileptic indication. The pregnancy outcomes were evaluated by follow-up interviews and by reference to hospital and treating doctors' records.
Over the first 30 months of the study (till December 2001) 334 eligible women were enrolled, with all states and territories being represented. Two hundred and ninety two pregnancies had been completed, of which 256 (88%) resulted in a healthy live birth, 19 (6.5%) a live birth with a birth defect, four an induced abortion because of a detected malformation on ultrasound, one premature labour with a stillbirth and 12 (4%) spontaneous abortions. Of the completed pregnancies, 269 were exposed to at least one AED during the first trimester. The incidence of birth defects in relation to specific AEDs was: valproate (16.7%), phenytoin (10.5%), lamotrigine (7.7%) and carbamazepine (3.3%), none of which was significantly different from that in women with epilepsy not taking an AED (4.3%, n.s.). The dose of valproate taken was higher in pregnancies with BD compared to those without (mean 2081 mg vs. 1149 mg, p<0.0001). The incidence of folate supplementation being taken prior to conception did not differ for pregnancy outcomes with or without BD (70% vs. 66%, n.s.).
The model for the Australian Pregnancy Register appears to be successful, with strong enrolment from all regions over the first 30 months. The study is prospective and includes reference to all new AEDs approved in Australia over the past decade. Analysis of the pregnancy outcomes to date may reveal early trends, but numbers are still to small for any definitive conclusions to be made regarding the relative risk in pregnancy of individual AEDs.
大多数癫痫女性在孕期需要服用抗癫痫药物(AEDs)以预防癫痫发作可能产生的有害影响。回顾性研究表明,服用AEDs的癫痫女性生育出生缺陷(BD)患儿的几率增加。目前尚不确定这种风险中有多少是由AEDs直接导致的,以及某些药物或药物组合是否与更高的风险相关。
建立一个登记系统,以前瞻性评估暴露于特定AEDs的女性不良妊娠结局的发生率;确定某些AEDs或药物组合是否与更高的风险相关;并确定其他因素是否会影响风险。
一项全澳大利亚范围的、前瞻性的、自愿参与的、基于电话访谈的观察性登记研究。招募了三组孕妇:服用AEDs的癫痫患者、未服用AEDs的癫痫患者以及因非癫痫适应症服用AEDs的患者。通过随访访谈以及参考医院和主治医生的记录来评估妊娠结局。
在研究的前30个月(至2001年12月),共招募了334名符合条件的女性,所有州和领地均有代表。292例妊娠已结束,其中256例(88%)分娩出健康活婴,19例(6.5%)分娩出有出生缺陷的活婴,4例因超声检查发现畸形而引产终止妊娠,1例早产伴死产,12例(4%)自然流产。在已结束的妊娠中,269例在孕早期至少接触过一种AEDs。与特定AEDs相关的出生缺陷发生率分别为:丙戊酸盐(16.7%)、苯妥英(10.5%)、拉莫三嗪(7.7%)和卡马西平(3.3%),这些均与未服用AEDs的癫痫女性的出生缺陷发生率(4.3%,无显著差异)无显著差异。与无出生缺陷的妊娠相比,有出生缺陷的妊娠中丙戊酸盐的服用剂量更高(平均2081毫克对1149毫克,p<0.0001)。无论妊娠结局有无出生缺陷,受孕前服用叶酸补充剂的发生率无差异(70%对66%,无显著差异)。
澳大利亚妊娠登记系统的模式似乎是成功的,在最初的30个月里所有地区的参与度都很高。该研究是前瞻性的,涵盖了过去十年在澳大利亚获批的所有新型AEDs。对目前妊娠结局的分析可能会揭示早期趋势,但就个体AEDs在妊娠中的相对风险得出任何确定性结论,目前样本数量仍太少。